arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2412.02889cs.AIq-bio.BM
收藏

基于深度学习的对接方法:与传统对接工作流程的公平比较

Deep-Learning Based Docking Methods: Fair Comparisons to Conventional Docking Workflows

BioPharmics Division(生物药物学部门);Optibrium Ltd.(Optibrium有限公司);Relay Therapeutics(Relay治疗公司)

Ajay N. Jain, Ann E. Cleves, W. Patrick Walters

AI总结:

本研究针对深度学习对接方法DiffDock宣称的性能优势,用传统对接工具构建公平基准,实验证明传统方法表现更优,且DiffDock性能依赖训练集近邻样本、泛化性不足。

摘要:

近期,用于将小分子配体对接到蛋白质结合位点的扩散学习方法DiffDock(扩散对接)被提出。其研究结果包含了与更传统对接方法的比较,显示DiffDock性能更优。本文中,我们采用基于Surflex-Dock(瑟夫莱克斯对接)方法的全自动工作流程,为传统对接方法生成公平的基准。我们针对结合位点位置已知的常见预期情况,以及结合位点未知的情况分别生成了结果。\n在结合位点已知的条件下,Surflex-Dock在均方根偏差(RMSD)为2.0埃时的成功率远超DiffDock:其Top-1/Top-5成功率分别为68%/81%,而DiffDock仅为45%/51%。Glide(格莱德)在结合位点已知条件下的成功率与Surflex-Dock相近(67%/73%),AutoDock Vina(自动对接维纳)和Gnina(吉纳)的结果也遵循这一模式。在结合位点未知的条件下,使用自动化方法识别多个结合口袋时,Surflex-Dock的成功率再次超过DiffDock,但差距略小。\nDiffDock使用约17000个共晶结构(占PDBBind 2020版2019年之前结构的98%)作为训练集,以预测2019年及之后的363个测试用例(占PDBBind 2020的2%)。对于超过半数的测试集用例,DiffDock的性能与训练集中存在近乎相同的蛋白质-配体复合物近邻案例密不可分。在近邻案例(占所有测试用例的三分之二)上,DiffDock的性能与没有近邻训练案例的情况相比相差40个百分点。DiffDock显然在学习过程中编码了一种查表机制,导致其无法实现有意义的泛化应用。此外,它的性能甚至远不及运行得当的现代对接工作流程。

英文摘要:

The diffusion learning method, DiffDock, for docking small-molecule ligands into protein binding sites was recently introduced. Results included comparisons to more conventional docking approaches, with DiffDock showing superior performance. Here, we employ a fully automatic workflow using the Surflex-Dock methods to generate a fair baseline for conventional docking approaches. Results were generated for the common and expected situation where a binding site location is known and also for the condition of an unknown binding site. For the known binding site condition, Surflex-Dock success rates at 2.0 Angstroms RMSD far exceeded those for DiffDock (Top-1/Top-5 success rates, respectively, were 68/81% compared with 45/51%). Glide performed with similar success rates (67/73%) to Surflex-Dock for the known binding site condition, and results for AutoDock Vina and Gnina followed this pattern. For the unknown binding site condition, using an automated method to identify multiple binding pockets, Surflex-Dock success rates again exceeded those of DiffDock, but by a somewhat lesser margin. DiffDock made use of roughly 17,000 co-crystal structures for learning (98% of PDBBind version 2020, pre-2019 structures) for a training set in order to predict on 363 test cases (2% of PDBBind 2020) from 2019 forward. DiffDock's performance was inextricably linked with the presence of near-neighbor cases of close to identical protein-ligand complexes in the training set for over half of the test set cases. DiffDock exhibited a 40 percentage point difference on near-neighbor cases (two-thirds of all test cases) compared with cases with no near-neighbor training case. DiffDock has apparently encoded a type of table-lookup during its learning process, rendering meaningful applications beyond its reach. Further, it does not perform even close to competitively with a competently run modern docking workflow.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑