支架还是拐杖?考察大学生对生成式AI工具在STEM教育中的使用与看法
Scaffold or Crutch? Examining College Students' Use and Views of Generative AI Tools for STEM Education
AI总结:
本研究通过调查美国40名STEM学生与28名教师,发现genAI虽被高频用于答疑和学习支持,但学生常直接让AI生成解答,可能削弱问题解决能力,并据此提出恰当使用与工具设计建议。
摘要:
培养问题解决能力是科学、技术、工程和数学(STEM)教育的核心,然而将这一优先事项转化为有效的问题解决教学与评估方法仍是一项重大挑战。近来,ChatGPT等生成式人工智能(genAI)工具在高等教育中的迅速普及,引发了关于这些工具如何帮助或阻碍学生发展STEM问题解决能力的新思考。我们的研究通过考察大学生如何以及为何在STEM课程作业中使用genAI工具来审视这些问题,重点关注其对问题解决的支持。我们调查了来自美国不同机构的40名STEM专业大学生和28名STEM教师,以了解教师对STEM课程中有效使用genAI工具及相关指导的看法。研究结果显示,STEM学生对genAI工具的采用率很高,应用方式多样。最常见的使用场景包括查找解释、探索相关主题、总结阅读材料以及帮助解答习题集问题。使用genAI工具的主要动机是节省时间。此外,超过一半的学生参与者报告称,他们只是简单地输入题目让AI生成解答,这可能会绕过他们自身的问题解决过程。这些发现表明,尽管采用率很高,但学生目前使用genAI工具的方式往往不足以提升其自身的STEM问题解决能力。本研究还探讨了学生和STEM教师对在STEM教育中使用genAI工具所带来的益处与风险的看法。我们的研究结果为如何指导学生在STEM课程中恰当使用genAI,以及如何设计基于genAI的工具以培养学生的问题解决能力提供了洞见。
英文摘要:
Developing problem-solving competency is central to Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) education, yet translating this priority into effective approaches to problem-solving instruction and assessment remain a significant challenge. The recent proliferation of generative artificial intelligence (genAI) tools like ChatGPT in higher education introduces new considerations about how these tools can help or hinder students' development of STEM problem-solving competency. Our research examines these considerations by studying how and why college students use genAI tools in their STEM coursework, focusing on their problem-solving support. We surveyed 40 STEM college students from diverse U.S. institutions and 28 STEM faculty to understand instructor perspectives on effective genAI tool use and guidance in STEM courses. Our findings reveal high adoption rates and diverse applications of genAI tools among STEM students. The most common use cases include finding explanations, exploring related topics, summarizing readings, and helping with problem-set questions. The primary motivation for using genAI tools was to save time. Moreover, over half of student participants reported simply inputting problems for AI to generate solutions, potentially bypassing their own problem-solving processes. These findings indicate that despite high adoption rates, students' current approaches to utilizing genAI tools often fall short in enhancing their own STEM problem-solving competencies. The study also explored students' and STEM instructors' perceptions of the benefits and risks associated with using genAI tools in STEM education. Our findings provide insights into how to guide students on appropriate genAI use in STEM courses and how to design genAI-based tools to foster students' problem-solving competency.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。