arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2411.01675cs.HC
收藏

感知与反击仇恨:身份认同在在线回应中的作用

Perceiving and Countering Hate: The Role of Identity in Online Responses

Virginia Tech(弗吉尼亚理工大学)

Kaike Ping, James Hawdon, Eugenia Rho

AI总结:

本研究探讨身份匹配度对在线反仇恨言论的影响,发现主题-身份匹配会影响仇恨感知与撰写体验,同时共情、篇幅等语言因素及AI工具使用经验也与反仇恨言论的撰写难度和效果相关,为相关技术和策略开发提供参考。

摘要:

本研究探讨了在线反仇恨言论(定义为对有害在线内容的直接回应,旨在劝阻发布者不再从事此类行为)如何受到仇恨言论目标与反仇恨言论撰写者身份匹配度的影响。研究以458名英语母语成年人为样本,他们对涉及种族、性别、宗教、性取向和残障状况的在线仇恨言论帖子做出回应。研究发现,仇恨帖子主题与反仇恨言论发布者身份的匹配度(主题-身份匹配,简称TIM)会影响对仇恨程度的感知以及撰写反仇恨言论的体验。具体而言,TIM显著提升了人们对种族和性取向相关帖子的仇恨感知程度。通常情况下,TIM能提高反仇恨言论发布者的满意度和对自身回应有效性的感知,同时降低撰写回应的难度,但针对性别相关仇恨言论的情况除外。此外,表现出更多共情、篇幅更长、语气更积极的反仇恨言论,其有效性评分和仇恨感知度也更高。过往使用ChatGPT等AI写作辅助工具的经验以及对这类工具的开放态度,与撰写在线反仇恨言论的感知难度呈负相关。总体而言,本研究为理解社交媒体上影响反仇恨言论的语言及身份相关因素提供了洞见,研究结果可为开发支持性技术和内容审核策略提供参考,以促进对在线仇恨的有效回应。

英文摘要:

This study investigates how online counterspeech, defined as direct responses to harmful online content with the intention of dissuading the perpetrator from further engaging in such behavior, is influenced by the match between a target of the hate speech and a counterspeech writer's identity. Using a sample of 458 English-speaking adults who responded to online hate speech posts covering race, gender, religion, sexual orientation, and disability status, our research reveals that the match between a hate post's topic and a counter-speaker's identity (topic-identity match, or TIM) shapes perceptions of hatefulness and experiences with counterspeech writing. Specifically, TIM significantly increases the perceived hatefulness of posts related to race and sexual orientation. TIM generally boosts counter-speakers' satisfaction and perceived effectiveness of their responses, and reduces the difficulty of crafting them, with an exception of gender-focused hate speech. In addition, counterspeech that displayed more empathy, was longer, had a more positive tone, and was associated with higher ratings of effectiveness and perceptions of hatefulness. Prior experience with, and openness to AI writing assistance tools like ChatGPT, correlate negatively with perceived difficulty in writing online counterspeech. Overall, this study contributes insights into linguistic and identity-related factors shaping counterspeech on social media. The findings inform the development of supportive technologies and moderation strategies for promoting effective responses to online hate.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑