在有限理性人口中的最优 paternalism 细微之处
The Subtlety of Optimal Paternalism in a Population with Bounded Rationality
AI总结:
研究探讨在有限理性人口中,最优 paternalism 需要规划者具备广泛知识,且需考虑规划者自身有限理性。
摘要:
我们研究了在有限理性人口中,当一个功利主义规划者有能力为一个异质性人口设计离散选择集时,最优 paternalism 的细微之处。我们首先在抽象层面上考虑规划问题。我们证明,最有效约束或影响选择的政策取决于人口偏好和选择概率的乘积,这些概率测量了行为的次优性。然后我们研究了两种情况,其中规划者可以下令某个行动或将决策权下放。一种情况假设个体在加法随机误差下测量效用,并最大化被错误测量而非实际效用。最优规划需要了解测量误差的分布。另一种情况研究二元治疗选择,当规划者可以根据公开观察到的个人协变量下令治疗,或允许个体根据私人信息选择自己的治疗。这里我们关注有限理性以主观和客观不确定结果概率之间的偏差形式。为了说明,我们考虑医学中的临床决策。总体而言,我们的警示分析表明,确定最优政策要求规划者拥有广泛的知识,这很少可用。我们警告行为公共经济学的研究应避免过于乐观的关于最优 paternalistic 政策性质的声明。我们主张对功利主义规划进行可信研究时,不仅要考虑人口,还要考虑规划者本身是有限理性的。
英文摘要:
We study the subtlety of optimal paternalism when a utilitarian planner has the power to design a discrete choice set for a heterogeneous population with bounded rationality. We first consider the planning problem in abstraction. We show that the policy that most effectively constrains or influences choices depends multiplicatively on the preferences of the population and the choice probabilities conditional on preferences that measure the suboptimality of behavior. We then study two settings in which the planner may mandate an action or decentralize decision making. One setting supposes that individuals measure utility with additive random error and maximize mismeasured rather than actual utility. Then optimal planning requires knowledge of the distribution of measurement errors. The other setting studies binary treatment choice when the planner can mandate a treatment conditional on publicly observed personal covariates or can enable individuals to choose their own treatments conditional on private information. Here we focus on situations where bounded rationality takes the form of deviations between subjective and objective probabilities of uncertain outcomes. To illustrate, we consider clinical decision making in medicine. In toto, our cautionary analysis shows that determination of optimal policy requires the planner to possess extensive knowledge that is rarely available. We warn that research in behavioral public economics should avoid overoptimistic claims regarding the nature of optimal paternalistic policies. We argue that credible study of utilitarian planning should consider not only the population but also the planner to be boundedly rational.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。