收敛于真理
Convergence to the Truth
AI总结:
本文回顾并发展了科学哲学中的收敛主义传统,强调应根据推理方法在多种场景下收敛于真理的能力进行评估,并将其与解释主义、工具主义和贝叶斯主义进行了比较。
摘要:
本文回顾并发展了科学哲学中的一个认识论传统,即 convergentism(收敛主义)。该传统认为,应根据推理方法在各种可能场景下收敛于真理的能力来对其进行评估。文章着重介绍了其在 C. S. Peirce 工作中的历史起源,以及在形式认识论和数据科学(包括统计学和机器学习)中的最新进展。文中还将其与另外三个传统进行了比较:(1) explanationism(解释主义),认为理论选择应受理论在解释力上的整体平衡(如简单性和与数据的拟合度)指导;(2) instrumentalism(工具主义),主张科学推断应由获取有用模型而非真实理论的目标驱动;(3) Bayesianism(贝叶斯主义),将焦点从非此即彼的信念转向信念度。
英文摘要:
This article reviews and develops an epistemological tradition in the philosophy of science, known as convergentism, which holds that inference methods should be assessed based on their ability to converge to the truth across a range of possible scenarios. Emphasis is placed on its historical origins in the work of C. S. Peirce and its recent developments in formal epistemology and data science (including statistics and machine learning). Comparisons are made with three other traditions: (1) explanationism, which holds that theory choice should be guided by a theory's overall balance of explanatory virtues, such as simplicity and fit with data; (2) instrumentalism, which maintains that scientific inference should be driven by the goal of obtaining useful models rather than true theories; and (3) Bayesianism, which shifts the focus from all-or-nothing beliefs to degrees of belief.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。