贝尔定理的最后一个漏洞?超决定论的一个初步问题
The Last Loophole in Bell's Theorem? A prima facie problem with superdeterminism
AI总结:
针对Hance等人提出的超决定论可让贝尔定理下定域性成立的观点,本文指出该决定论解释会与量子不确定性及不可对易性冲突,并探讨了相关宇宙学影响。
摘要:
Hance与Hossenfelder近期声称,贝尔定理的大量实验证实实际上并未证明自然界是非定域的,而仅表明:只有当贝尔-EPR实验装置中的远端探测器设置不具备统计独立性时,自然界才可能是定域的。他们提出,这种相互依存关系可以采取定域决定论的形式。毫无疑问,一般而言量子力学不仅允许而且要求远端探测器发生纠缠从而具有相关性,尽管我们可以开展可忽略此类相关性的实验。真正的问题在于,纠缠本身是否存在决定论的解释。我们梳理了为何任何这类试图为量子统计提供决定论基础的尝试,都会立刻与量子不确定性及其所依赖的不可对易性产生冲突。本文还简要探讨了部分宇宙学层面的影响。
英文摘要:
Hance and Hossenfelder recently claim that the extensive experimental confirmations of Bell's Theorem do not in fact demonstrate that nature is nonlocal, but merely that nature can be local only if the distant detector settings in a Bell-EPR setup are not statistically independent. They suggest that such interdependence could take a local-deterministic form. There is no question that in general quantum mechanics not only allows but demands that the distant detectors be entangled and thus correlated, even though it is possible to do experiments in which such correlations can be ignored. The real question is whether entanglement itself could have a deterministic explanation. We review why any such attempted deterministic underpinning for quantum statistics would run into immediate conflict with quantum indeterminacy and the noncommutativity upon which the latter is based. Some cosmological implications are briefly explored.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。