从感知到决策:评估图表类型可供性在高层决策任务中的作用
From Perception to Decision: Assessing the Role of Chart Types Affordances in High-Level Decision Tasks
AI总结:
本文通过学术导师选择实验发现,条形图与饼图的感知可供性差异几乎不影响高层决策结果,表明需在现实情境中区分感知可供性与决策可供性。
摘要:
可视化设计影响人们感知数据模式的方式,但大多数研究聚焦于低层次分析任务,例如寻找相关性。这些感知可供性在多大程度上转化为现实世界中的高层决策,仍未得到充分探索。通过对使用条形图和饼图进行学术导师选择的案例研究,我们考察了图表类型是否会对学生评估教师研究概况产生不同影响。我们的众包实验显示,不同图表类型之间的决策结果仅存在极小差异,这表明在受控分析任务中建立的感知可供性可能无法直接转化为高层决策场景。这些发现强调了在现实世界情境中评估可视化的重要性,并突显了在制定可视化指南时区分感知可供性与决策可供性的必要性。
英文摘要:
Visualization design influences how people perceive data patterns, yet most research focuses on low-level analytic tasks, such as finding correlations. The extent to which these perceptual affordances translate to high-level decision-making in the real world remains underexplored. Through a case study of academic mentorship selection using bar charts and pie charts, we investigated whether chart types differentially influence how students evaluate faculty research profiles. Our crowdsourced experiment revealed only minimal differences in decision outcomes between chart types, suggesting that perceptual affordances established in controlled analytical tasks may not directly translate to high-level decision scenarios. These findings emphasize the importance of evaluating visualizations within real-world contexts and highlight the need to distinguish between perceptual and decision affordances when developing visualization guidelines.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。