arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2410.04438stat.MEmath.STstat.APstat.TH
收藏

关于替代终点评估中错误设定不可识别因果推断模型的影响的反思

A Reflection on the Impact of Misspecifying Unidentifiable Causal Inference Models in Surrogate Endpoint Evaluation

Gokce Deliorman, Florian Stijven, Wim Van der Elst, Maria del Carmen Pardo, Ariel Alonso

AI总结:

该研究针对替代终点评估中部分可识别的因果推断模型设定错误问题,通过理论分析与蒙特卡洛模拟探究两种分布场景下的影响差异,并结合真实数据集验证不同模型的结果差异,为替代终点评估的模型选择提供参考。

摘要:

在临床试验中,替代终点常被用来替代成本高昂、获取延迟或较为罕见的真实终点,但监管机构需要对其进行全面评估,才能认可这些替代终点作为可靠的替代指标。信息论因果推断框架是一种评估方法,它通过个体因果关联(ICA)来量化代理效应。与大多数因果推断方法一样,该方法依赖于仅部分可识别的模型。对于连续型结局,通常采用正态模型。基于理论要素和蒙特卡洛方法,我们在两种场景下研究了模型设定错误的影响:1)真实模型基于多元t分布;2)真实模型基于多元对数正态分布。在第一种场景中,模型设定错误对结果的影响可以忽略不计;而在第二种场景中,当设定错误可通过观测数据检测到时,其影响十分显著。最后,我们使用正态模型和若干D-vine copula模型分析了两个数据集,这些D-vine copula模型基于现有数据与正态模型无法区分,我们观察到使用不同模型时结果可能存在差异。

英文摘要:

Surrogate endpoints are often used in place of expensive, delayed, or rare true endpoints in clinical trials. However, regulatory authorities require thorough evaluation to accept these surrogate endpoints as reliable substitutes. One evaluation approach is the information-theoretic causal inference framework, which quantifies surrogacy using the individual causal association (ICA). Like most causal inference methods, this approach relies on models that are only partially identifiable. For continuous outcomes, a normal model is often used. Based on theoretical elements and a Monte Carlo procedure we studied the impact of model misspecification across two scenarios: 1) the true model is based on a multivariate t-distribution, and 2) the true model is based on a multivariate log-normal distribution. In the first scenario, the misspecification has a negligible impact on the results, while in the second, it has a significant impact when the misspecification is detectable using the observed data. Finally, we analyzed two data sets using the normal model and several D-vine copula models that were indistinguishable from the normal model based on the data at hand. We observed that the results may vary when different models are used.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑