arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2409.14137cs.HC
收藏

对可能的未来进行三角验证:针对多个而非仅一个未来开展用户研究

Triangulating on Possible Futures: Conducting User Studies on Several Futures Instead of Only One

Antti Salovaara, Leevi Vahvelainen

AI总结:

针对HCI未来用户研究结论易特殊化、缺乏普适性的问题,提出对多个可能未来进行三角验证的方法,经AI增强知识工作的两种未来场景研究验证,可交叉核验可信度、深化洞见,提升研究的未来适应性。

摘要:

关于未来的可信发现本质上难以获取,因为它们需要有数据支撑的、具备批判性且信息充分的推测。人机交互(HCI)领域的学者通过用户研究应对这一挑战:在研究中,未来主义原型和其他道具为参与者将可能的未来具象化。通过观察参与者的行为,研究者得以“时间旅行”,观察该未来作为现实落地运行的状态。然而,此类研究可能产生受研究复杂特性影响的特殊化发现,缺乏更广泛的可信度。本文提出,对可能的未来进行三角验证可帮助研究者区分特殊结论与更具普适性的发现。我们通过开展一项针对AI增强型知识工作的两种替代未来的研究,探索了该方法。部分发现在两种未来情境中均出现,其余则仅为某一种未来所特有。该方法实现了可信度的交叉核验,同时提供了更深入的洞见。本文讨论了对可能的未来进行三角验证如何让HCI研究更具未来适应性,并为反思性预判可能的未来提供了方法。

英文摘要:

Plausible findings about futures are inherently difficult to obtain as they require critical, well-informed speculations backed with data. HCI scholars tackle this challenge via user studies wherein futuristic prototypes and other props concretise possible futures for participants. By observing participants' actions, researchers then can 'time travel' to see that future as reality, in action. However, such studies may yield particularised findings, inherent to study's intricacies, and lack broader plausibility. This paper suggests that triangulation of possible futures may help researchers disentangle particularities from more generalisable findings. We explored this approach by conducting a study on two alternative futures of AI-augmented knowledge work. Some findings emerged in both futures while others were particular to only one or the other. This approach enabled cross-checking of plausibility and simultaneously afforded deeper insight. The paper discusses how triangulating possible futures renders HCI studies more future-proof and provides means for reflective anticipation of possible futures.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑