捕捉不同社群间角色表征的差异:基于Fandom的初步研究
Capturing Differences in Character Representations Between Communities: An Initial Study with Fandom
AI总结:
本研究以《哈利·波特》相关两个同人社群及原作为对象,通过计算方法分析角色提及、共现网络中心性与语义关联,发现不同社群角色表征存在显著差异,验证了计算方法辅助跨社群叙事重构研究的潜力。
摘要:
社会语言学理论已强调,叙事在协作场景中往往会被重述、共同建构并重新概念化。本工作论文聚焦于角色这一叙事故事世界的核心组成部分的重新解读,尝试研究如何通过计算方法对比不同在线社群间的角色解读差异。研究以在线Fandom(同人圈,一种已被大量定性研究的高度社群化现象)为数据,采用计算方法探索两个同人社群与原始文本之间角色表征的变化。具体而言,研究分析了《哈利·波特》系列小说、r/HarryPotter子版块以及Archive of Our Own(AO3,我们的存档)上的同人小说文本,考察角色提及量、共现网络的中心性指标以及语义关联的变化。与过往研究结论一致,同人圈提升了次要角色的地位,但两个同人社群侧重的角色子集各不相同。词嵌入测试显示,不同社群对同一角色在女性气质/男性气质、残忍度和美貌这类性别相关概念上的关联存在显著差异。此外,针对某一男性角色的同人小说描述在不同浪漫配对中的分析显示,男男浪漫配对中的该角色女性化特征得分更高,这与过往的定性理论推论相符。研究结果凸显了计算方法在捕捉跨社群叙事元素重新概念化、支持同人圈定性研究方面的潜力。
英文摘要:
Sociolinguistic theories have highlighted how narratives are often retold, co-constructed and reconceptualized in collaborative settings. This working paper focuses on the re-interpretation of characters, an integral part of the narrative story-world, and attempts to study how this may be computationally compared between online communities. Using online fandom - a highly communal phenomenon that has been largely studied qualitatively - as data, computational methods were applied to explore shifts in character representations between two communities and the original text. Specifically, text from the Harry Potter novels, r/HarryPotter subreddit, and fanfiction on Archive of Our Own were analyzed for changes in character mentions, centrality measures from co-occurrence networks, and semantic associations. While fandom elevates secondary characters as found in past work, the two fan communities prioritize different subsets of characters. Word embedding tests reveal starkly different associations of the same characters between communities on the gendered concepts of femininity/masculinity, cruelty, and beauty. Furthermore, fanfiction descriptions of a male character analyzed between romance pairings scored higher for feminine-coded characteristics in male-male romance, matching past qualitative theorizing. The results high-light the potential for computational methods to assist in capturing the re-conceptualization of narrative elements across communities and in supporting qualitative research on fandom.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。