arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2409.10841cs.HC
收藏

深色模式还是浅色模式?探索对比极性对不同年龄组可视化性能的影响

Dark Mode or Light Mode? Exploring the Impact of Contrast Polarity on Visualization Performance Between Age Groups

Zack While, Ali Sarvghad

AI总结:

本研究通过众包实验考察对比极性对不同年龄组可视化性能的影响,发现性能最优极性存在个体差异且与偏好未必一致,其对耗时影响与可视化类型相近,且效果未随年龄显著变化,强调需提供双极性可视化。

摘要:

本研究考察了正、负对比极性(即浅色和深色模式)对年轻人与成年晚期人群(PLA)的性能影响。在一项有134名参与者(69名60岁以下,66名60岁及以上)参与的众包研究中,我们评估了他们在三种常见可视化类型(柱状图、折线图、散点图)和两种对比极性(正、负)下执行分析任务的准确率和耗时。我们观察到,在两个年龄组中,能带来更优性能的极性以及相应的提升幅度均存在个体差异,两种极性使相当比例的参与者受益。然而,能带来更优性能的对比极性并不总是与他们偏好的极性一致。此外,我们发现对比极性的选择对耗时的影响与可视化类型的选择相近,导致平均百分比差异约为36%。这些发现表明,总体而言,对比极性对视觉分析性能的影响并未随年龄发生显著变化。此外,它们强调了提供两种对比极性的可视化的重要性,以更好地支持具有不同需求的广泛受众。本研究的补充材料可在https://osf.io/539a4/获取。

英文摘要:

This study examines the impact of positive and negative contrast polarities (i.e., light and dark modes) on the performance of younger adults and people in their late adulthood (PLA). In a crowdsourced study with 134 participants (69 below age 60, 66 aged 60 and above), we assessed their accuracy and time performing analysis tasks across three common visualization types (Bar, Line, Scatterplot) and two contrast polarities (positive and negative). We observed that, across both age groups, the polarity that led to better performance and the resulting amount of improvement varied on an individual basis, with each polarity benefiting comparable proportions of participants. However, the contrast polarity that led to better performance did not always match their preferred polarity. Additionally, we observed that the choice of contrast polarity can have an impact on time similar to that of the choice of visualization type, resulting in an average percent difference of around 36%. These findings indicate that, overall, the effects of contrast polarity on visual analysis performance do not noticeably change with age. Furthermore, they underscore the importance of making visualizations available in both contrast polarities to better-support a broad audience with differing needs. Supplementary materials for this work can be found at https://osf.io/539a4/.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑