arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2409.10549cs.CYmath.OC
收藏

直面冲突直至同意:用开放设计系统解开棘手难题

Confronting Conflicts to Yes: Untangling Wicked Problems with Open Design Systems

L. G. Teuber, A. R. M. Wolfert

AI总结:

本文提出基于 Odesys 开放设计系统和 CBCA 方法的先验设计途径,将争议性外生因素内生化,以荷兰风电场僵局为例,实现多利益相关者协作达成“同意”。

摘要:

当前的项目开发实践往往无法尽早且有效地让利益相关者参与进来。决策支持常常缺乏包容性、只呈现单方面观点且透明度不足,而复杂性又超出了人类的理解能力。此外,许多方法主要关注技术系统层面,忽视了利益相关者个体偏好的整合。这常常导致项目陷入僵局,使利益相关者无法协作达成“同意”。因此,需要一种纯粹关联性的、先验的设计方法,在联合的社会-技术解决方案空间内整合系统现实与利益相关者理想。最先进的 Preferendus 工具嵌入在经验证的 Open Design Systems (Odesys) 方法论中,是一种将复杂性转化为成功的中立工具。Odesys 以综合为目标,其稳健的 IMAP 优化方法能够生成单一的最佳拟合设计方案。本文中,Odesys 被应用于一个荷兰风电场僵局开发项目,以平衡多个利益相关者偏好、风电场性能和项目约束。该方法能否成功取决于利益相关者的信任与投入。本文引入了一种结构化的利益相关者评估方法,采用基于选择的合取分析(CBCA),有助于透明地确定全局和局部利益相关者权重及偏好函数。通过将“有争议的”外生因素建模为内生设计参数,该应用展示了如何转向协作性的“同意”。为此,本文得出结论:一个放大视野的解决方案空间将使能源转型能够以多种选项而非单一规定选项来应对。Odesys 方法促进了符合自由、平等、博爱这三项社会原则的决策,引导项目走向真正的民主成果,而不是从精心策划的选项中做出选择。

英文摘要:

Current project development practices often fail to engage stakeholders early and effectively. Decision support is often non-inclusive, single-sided, and lacking in transparency, while complexity goes beyond human's comprehension. Additionally, many approaches focus primarily on technical system aspects, neglecting the integration of stakeholders' individual preferences. This often results in project impasses, leaving stakeholders unable to collaboratively achieve a "yes." There is a need for a purely associative, a-priori design approach that integrates system realities and stakeholder ideals within a joint socio-technical solution space. The state-of-the-art Preferendus, embedded in the proven Open Design Systems (Odesys) methodology, is a neutral tool for transforming complexity into success. Aiming for synthesis, Odesys' robust IMAP optimization method generates a single best-fit design solution. Here, Odesys is applied for a Dutch wind farm stalemate development, balancing multiple stakeholder preferences, wind farm performances, and project constraints. The success of this approach hinges on stakeholder trust and input. This article introduces a structured stakeholder assessment method using choice-based conjunctive analysis (CBCA), facilitating transparent determination of global and local stakeholder weights and preference functions. Modelling 'disputable' exogenous factors as endogenous design parameters, the application demonstrates how one can shift toward a collaborative "yes." For this, it is concluded that a zoomed-out solution space would enable the energy transition to be tackled with multiple options rather than a prescribed one. The Odesys approach fosters decision-making that aligns with the social threefold principles of freedom, equality, and fraternity, guiding projects toward genuine democratic outcomes rather than selecting from curated options.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑