arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2409.06852cs.DL
收藏

科学文献中隐秘更正的存在——对科学诚信的威胁

The existence of stealth corrections in scientific literature -- a threat to scientific integrity

Rene Aquarius, Floris Schoeters, Nick Wise, Alex Glynn, Guillaume Cabanac

AI总结:

该研究证实科学文献中存在无公示的隐秘更正现象,报道了2005-2024年间131篇涉及多领域多出版商的相关文章,并提出透明追踪变更、明确更正规则、推动公众监督三项建议以维护科学诚信。

摘要:

引言:为确保科学记录内容的可信度,需要对其进行全面维护。而隐秘更正(即对已发表科学文章进行至少一次发表后修改,且不提供更正说明或任何表明该出版物已被临时或永久改动的提示)会破坏这种可信度。本文列举了若干隐秘更正的实例,以证明这类现象存在于科学文献中。据我们所知,此前科学文献中尚无此类隐秘更正的相关记录报道。\n方法:我们自行识别了部分隐秘更正,也通过公共数据库pubpeer.com或是知名科学核查人员的社交媒体账号发现了一些已被报道的隐秘更正。\n结果:本研究共报道了131篇受隐秘更正影响的文章,它们发表于2005年至2024年间,涉及多家出版机构与多个科学领域。\n结论与建议:科学文献中确实存在隐秘更正现象。由于其威胁科学诚信,必须立即杜绝这种情况。我们提出以下建议:1)所有出版机构以开放、统一、透明的方式追踪已发表记录的所有变更,最好通过可公开记录每一处修改的在线投稿系统实现,从根源上杜绝隐秘更正;2)针对各类更正制定明确的定义与指南;3)支持科学界保持持续警惕,对隐秘更正进行公开登记。

英文摘要:

Introduction: Thorough maintenance of the scientific record is needed to ensure the trustworthiness of its content. This can be undermined by a stealth correction, which is at least one post-publication change made to a scientific article, without providing a correction note or any other indicator that the publication was temporarily or permanently altered. In this paper we provide several examples of stealth corrections in order to demonstrate that these exist within the scientific literature. As far as we are aware, no documentation of such stealth corrections was previously reported in the scientific literature. Methods: We identified stealth corrections ourselves, or found already reported ones on the public database pubpeer.com or through social media accounts of known science sleuths. Results: In total we report 131 articles that were affected by stealth corrections and were published between 2005 and 2024. These stealth corrections were found among multiple publishers and scientific fields. Conclusion: and recommendations Stealth corrections exist in the scientific literature. This needs to end immediately as it threatens scientific integrity. We recommend the following: 1) Tracking all changes to the published record by all publishers in an open, uniform and transparent manner, preferably by online submission systems that log every change publicly, making stealth corrections impossible; 2) Clear definitions and guidelines on all types of corrections; 3) Support sustained vigilance of the scientific community to publicly register stealth corrections.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑