arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2409.05161stat.ME
收藏

超越任意重复:因果推断中模拟设计的原则性方法

Beyond Arbitrary Replications: A Principled Approach to Simulation Design in Causal Inference

Hugo Gobato Souto, Francisco Louzada Neto

AI总结:

针对模拟研究中任意重复次数的问题,提出测试信息模拟计数算法(TISCA),结合t检验与功效分析确定统计上合理的模拟次数,节省资源并提供可靠证据。

摘要:

对新治疗效应估计器的评估通常依赖于缺乏正式统计比较且使用任意重复次数($J$)的模拟研究。这阻碍了可重复性和效率。我们提出测试信息模拟计数算法(TISCA)来解决这些缺陷。TISCA将Welch的t检验与功效分析相结合,迭代运行模拟,直到在给定显著性水平($α$)下检测用户定义的最小可检测效应量(MDE)达到预设功效(例如0.8)。这产生了具有统计依据的模拟计数($J$)和严格的模型比较。我们的文献计量研究证实了当前关于$J$实践的异质性。一项重新审视McJames等人(2024)的案例研究表明,TISCA识别出足够的模拟次数($J=500$,而原始为$J=1000$),在节省计算资源的同时提供了统计上可靠的证据。TISCA促进了因果推断及其他领域中严谨、高效和可持续的模拟实践。

英文摘要:

Evaluation of novel treatment effect estimators frequently relies on simulation studies lacking formal statistical comparisons and using arbitrary numbers of replications ($J$). This hinders reproducibility and efficiency. We propose the Test-Informed Simulation Count Algorithm (TISCA) to address these shortcomings. TISCA integrates Welch's t-tests with power analysis, iteratively running simulations until a pre-specified power (e.g., 0.8) is achieved for detecting a user-defined minimum detectable effect size (MDE) at a given significance level ($α$). This yields a statistically justified simulation count ($J$) and rigorous model comparisons. Our bibliometric study confirms the heterogeneity of current practices regarding $J$. A case study revisiting McJames et al. (2024) demonstrates TISCA identifies sufficient simulations ($J=500$ vs. original $J=1000$), saving computational resources while providing statistically sound evidence. TISCA promotes rigorous, efficient, and sustainable simulation practices in causal inference and beyond.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑