arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2409.01118cs.SE
收藏

公共部门采购开源软件解决方案中的软锁定:一项关于市政电子服务平台案例研究

Soft-lockins in Public Sector Acquisitions of Open Source Software-solutions: A Case Study on a Municipal E-Service Platform

Per Persson, Johan Linåker

AI总结:

通过对190多个市政当局使用的电子服务平台进行案例研究,识别出用户驱动和技术性软锁定因素,并提出由开源管家支持领导力与培训以构建开放供应商生态的应对策略。

摘要:

背景:开源软件(OSS)常被视为降低锁定风险的一种选择。然而,单一供应商的OSS仍可能因知识不对称和技术壁垒而导致软锁定。目的:本研究探讨造成此类软锁定的参与者。研究设计:我们对一个被190多个市政当局使用的电子服务平台(ESP)进行了定性案例研究。结果:用户驱动的锁定因素成为一个重要类别,包括有限且不透明的沟通、采购中限制性的资质要求、对维护责任的混淆以及对现状的安于舒适。技术锁定因素包括文档不充分、依赖管理问题以及测试覆盖率有限。结论:需要强有力的领导力和持续培训来应对市政当局中存在的安于舒适和保守文化。开源管家(Open Source Stewards),即OSS项目的中立托管方,可以支持市政当局完成这些任务,同时也有助于培育开放、竞争性的协作,从而促成更广泛的供应商生态系统。

英文摘要:

Background: Open Source Software (OSS) is often seen as an option to mitigate risks of lock-ins. Yet, single-vendor OSS can still result in soft lock-ins due to knowledge asymmetries and technical barriers. Aim: This study explores actors that render such soft lock-ins. Research design: We conduct a qualitative case study of an E-service Platform (ESP) used by over 190+ municipalities. Results: User-driven lock-in factors emerged as a significant category, including limited and non-transparent communication, restrictive qualification requirements in procurement, confusion on maintainership, and comfort in the status quo. Technical lock-in factors include inadequate documentation, dependency management issues, and limited test coverage. Conclusions: Strong leadership and continuous training is needed to address presence of comfort and conservative culture among municipalities. Open Source Stewards, i.e., neutral hosts for OSS projects, can support municipalities in these tasks while also helping to foster an open, competitive collaboration that can enable a broader supplier ecosystem.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑