抗体测量的不确定性量化:物理原理及其对标准化的意义
Uncertainty Quantification of Antibody Measurements: Physical Principles and Implications for Standardization
AI总结:
本文建立抗体归一化与协调的严格理论及概率框架,结合热力学和不确定性传播方法量化保护相关性,证明参考物质选择不增加不确定性,并以单克隆抗体用于SARS-CoV-2血清学标准化为例验证。
摘要:
协调血清学测量对于确定参考物质至关重要,这些参考物质能够在不同诊断平台之间实现结果的标准化和比较。然而,在抗体热力学和不确定性量化(UQ)的背景下,此类任务的理论基础尚未得到充分探索。这限制了当前所部署标准的有用性,并缩小了被视为可行参考物质的材料范围。为了解决这些问题,我们建立了严格的抗体归一化与协调理论,并构建了一个用于定义保护相关性的概率框架。我们首先提出了协调的数学定义,并赋予其量化与标准选择、检测方法等相关的不确定性所需的结构。随后,我们展示了血清学测量的热力学描述如何(i)将该结构与抗体结合的吉布斯自由能联系起来,并由此(ii)推导出一种直接协调测量的回归分析方法。我们进一步补充了一种新颖的、基于优化的归一化(而非协调!)方法,用于检验参考稀释曲线与样本稀释曲线之间的一致性。最后,我们将这些分析与不确定性传播技术联系起来,以估计保护相关性。这些分析的一个关键结果是,在物理上合理的条件下,参考物质的选择不会增加与协调或保护相关性相关的不确定性。我们提供了示例,并在一项实验室间研究的背景下验证了主要思想,该研究为使用单克隆抗体作为SARS-CoV-2血清学测量的参考奠定了基础。
英文摘要:
Harmonizing serology measurements is critical for identifying reference materials that permit standardization and comparison of results across different diagnostic platforms. However, the theoretical foundations of such tasks have yet to be fully explored in the context of antibody thermodynamics and uncertainty quantification (UQ). This has restricted the usefulness of standards currently deployed and limited the scope of materials considered as viable reference material. To address these problems, we develop rigorous theories of antibody normalization and harmonization, as well as formulate a probabilistic framework for defining correlates of protection. We begin by proposing a mathematical definition of harmonization equipped with structure needed to quantify uncertainty associated with the choice of standard, assay, etc. We then show how a thermodynamic description of serology measurements (i) relates this structure to the Gibbs free-energy of antibody binding, and thereby (ii) induces a regression analysis that directly harmonizes measurements. We supplement this with a novel, optimization-based normalization (not harmonization!) method that checks for consistency between reference and sample dilution curves. Last, we relate these analyses to uncertainty propagation techniques to estimate correlates of protection. A key result of these analyses is that under physically reasonable conditions, the choice of reference material does not increase uncertainty associated with harmonization or correlates of protection. We provide examples and validate main ideas in the context of an interlab study that lays the foundation for using monoclonal antibodies as a reference for SARS-CoV-2 serology measurements.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。