治理范式的导航:生成式人工智能治理过程与原则的跨区域比较研究
Navigating Governance Paradigms: A Cross-Regional Comparative Study of Generative AI Governance Processes & Principles
AI总结:
本文通过构建协调一致的H-GenAIGF框架,对欧盟、美国、中国等六个区域的生成式人工智能治理过程与原则进行跨区域比较,发现基于风险的方法覆盖更优,并揭示现有治理缺乏一致且可执行的规定。
摘要:
随着生成式人工智能(GenAI)技术以前所未有的速度演进,全球治理方法难以跟上技术发展的步伐,这凸显了治理适应重大挑战中的一个关键问题。描绘全球不同区域基于风险、规则、结果、原则或混合方式的、尚处于初期且多样化的治理方法的细微差别,对于识别差异与趋同、并揭示需要解决的具体局限至关重要,从而促进GenAI的安全和可信采用。针对这一需求以及GenAI不断演变的性质,本文旨在提供全球不同治理方法的整体视图。我们的研究引入了一个协调一致的GenAI框架“H-GenAIGF”,该框架基于六个区域的当前治理方法:欧盟(EU)、美国(US)、中国(CN)、加拿大(CA)、英国(UK)和新加坡(SG)。我们确定了四个组成部分、十五个过程、二十五个子过程和九项原则,以辅助GenAI的治理,从而为GenAI治理的现状提供了一个全面的视角。此外,我们提出了一项比较分析,以基于每个区域对过程的覆盖情况来促进共同点和差异的识别。结果表明,基于风险的方法能够更好地覆盖这些过程,其次是混合方法。其他方法则落后,覆盖的过程不到50%。最突出的是,分析表明,在各区域中,只有一个过程在所有方法中保持一致,这凸显了缺乏一致且可执行的规定。此外,我们对ChatGPT的案例研究揭示了过程覆盖的不足,表明方法的协调一致对于找到GenAI治理的共识是必要的。
英文摘要:
As Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) technologies evolve at an unprecedented rate, global governance approaches struggle to keep pace with the technology, highlighting a critical issue in the governance adaptation of significant challenges. Depicting the nuances of nascent and diverse governance approaches based on risks, rules, outcomes, principles, or a mix across different regions around the globe is fundamental to discern discrepancies and convergences and to shed light on specific limitations that need to be addressed, thereby facilitating the safe and trustworthy adoption of GenAI. In response to the need and the evolving nature of GenAI, this paper seeks to provide a collective view of different governance approaches around the world. Our research introduces a Harmonized GenAI Framework, "H-GenAIGF," based on the current governance approaches of six regions: European Union (EU), United States (US), China (CN), Canada (CA), United Kingdom (UK), and Singapore (SG). We have identified four constituents, fifteen processes, twenty-five sub-processes, and nine principles that aid the governance of GenAI, thus providing a comprehensive perspective on the current state of GenAI governance. In addition, we present a comparative analysis to facilitate the identification of common ground and distinctions based on the coverage of the processes by each region. The results show that risk-based approaches allow for better coverage of the processes, followed by mixed approaches. Other approaches lag behind, covering less than 50% of the processes. Most prominently, the analysis demonstrates that among the regions, only one process aligns across all approaches, highlighting the lack of consistent and executable provisions. Moreover, our case study on ChatGPT reveals process coverage deficiency, showing that harmonization of approaches is necessary to find alignment for GenAI governance.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。