禁忌知识 artifacts 的生命史
Life Histories of Taboo Knowledge Artifacts
AI总结:
研究通过混合方法分析维基百科中禁忌主题知识 artifacts 的生成、发展及持续机制,揭示其在有限可识别性和碎片化意义建构中的韧性领导与协作模式。
摘要:
在一些至关重要的主题——如性与健康——上,交流被视为禁忌并受到审查。我们如何构建关于这些主题的知识?维基百科是许多高质量关于禁忌主题的知识 artifacts 的家园,如性器官和人类生殖。这些 artifacts 是如何产生的?它们的存在是如何持续的?本混合方法比较项目基于之前关于维基百科禁忌主题的工作,并借鉴了定性和定量方法。我们采用顺序互补设计,开发了禁忌文章的生命叙述,将其与非禁忌文章进行比较,并检验了一些可量化的特征。我们发现,禁忌知识 artifacts 通过多种成功的协作风格发展而成,并不出人意料的是,禁忌主题是冲突的场所。我们识别并描述了禁忌知识 artifacts 发展中的六个主题。这些 artifacts 需要坚韧的领导和积极参与的组织在有限可识别性和碎片化意义建构的条件下蓬勃发展,同时贡献者同时参与新兴治理和想象公共受众。我们的观察对支持在争议性主题如禁忌和更广泛领域上的公共知识工作有重要影响。
英文摘要:
Communicating about some vital topics -- such as sexuality and health -- is treated as taboo and subjected to censorship. How can we construct knowledge about these topics? Wikipedia is home to numerous high-quality knowledge artifacts about taboo topics like sexual organs and human reproduction. How did these artifacts come into being? How is their existence sustained? This mixed-methods comparative project builds on previous work on taboo topics in Wikipedia and draws from qualitative and quantitative approaches. We follow a sequential complementary design, developing a narrative articulation of the life of taboo articles, comparing them to nontaboo articles, and examining some of their quantifiable traits. We find that taboo knowledge artifacts develop through multiple successful collaboration styles and, unsurprisingly, that taboo subjects are the sites of conflict. We identify and describe six themes in the development of taboo knowledge artifacts. These artifacts need resilient leadership and engaged organizations to thrive under conditions of limited identifiability and disjointed sensemaking, while contributors simultaneously engage in emergent governance and imagining public audiences. Our observations have important implications for supporting public knowledge work on controversial subjects such as taboos and more generally.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。