约束参与:大语言模型交互界面中反馈功能的可供性
Constraining Participation: Affordances of Feedback Features in Interfaces to Large Language Models
AI总结:
本研究通过调查早期ChatGPT用户并运用可供性框架,发现其界面反馈功能鼓励简单性能导向反馈、阻碍集体讨论,指出这类约束或加剧权力失衡,为参与式AI研究提供反馈流程优化方向,倡导构建支持LLM相关持续对话的基础设施。
摘要:
如今,任何拥有电脑、网页浏览器和互联网连接的人都能通过基于浏览器的界面使用大语言模型(LLMs),这改变了AI开发中的参与格局。本文研究了ChatGPT界面中的交互式反馈功能如何为用户参与LLM迭代提供支持。我们通过对早期ChatGPT用户的调查,并运用可供性的机制与条件框架,分析了这些功能如何塑造用户输入。分析表明,这些功能鼓励简单、频繁且聚焦于性能的反馈,同时阻碍了用户间的集体输入与讨论。结合参与式设计文献,我们认为若这类约束在更广泛的用户群体中被复制,将有可能加剧用户、公众与LLM开发公司之间的权力失衡。我们的分析通过批判性审视现有反馈流程的局限性并提出重新设计的方向,为日益增长的参与式AI研究文献做出了贡献。我们主张创建支持围绕LLM的用途与应用展开持续对话的基础设施,而非仅关注使模型输出与特定用户偏好对齐。这一方法需要关注“基础设施化”的持续工作——即创建并维持必要的社会、技术与制度结构,以解决受LLM开发与部署影响的利益相关者所关切的问题。
英文摘要:
Large language models (LLMs) are now accessible to anyone with a computer, a web browser, and an internet connection via browser-based interfaces, shifting the dynamics of participation in AI development. This article examines how interactive feedback features in ChatGPT's interface afford user participation in LLM iteration. Drawing on a survey of early ChatGPT users and applying the mechanisms and conditions framework of affordances, we analyse how these features shape user input. Our analysis indicates that these features encourage simple, frequent, and performance-focused feedback while discouraging collective input and discussions among users. Drawing on participatory design literature, we argue such constraints, if replicated across broader user bases, risk reinforcing power imbalances between users, the public, and companies developing LLMs. Our analysis contributes to the growing literature on participatory AI by critically examining the limitations of existing feedback processes and proposing directions for redesign. Rather than focusing solely on aligning model outputs with specific user preferences, we advocate for creating infrastructure that supports sustained dialogue about the purpose and applications of LLMs. This approach requires attention to the ongoing work of "infrastructuring" - creating and sustaining the social, technical, and institutional structures necessary to address matters of concern to stakeholders impacted by LLM development and deployment.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。