arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2408.14937cs.CR
收藏

从混乱到一致性:CSAF在简化安全公告中的作用

From Chaos to Consistency: The Role of CSAF in Streamlining Security Advisories

Julia Wunder, Janik Aurich, Zinaida Benenson

AI总结:

本研究通过专家访谈和197人参与的在线调查,探讨了安全公告当前存在的问题及CSAF标准的解决能力,发现尽管CSAF能解决格式不一致等问题,但因系统未适配自动化及迁移成本高,目前使用率低且用户对自动化持怀疑态度。

摘要:

安全公告已成为漏洞管理的重要组成部分。它们可用于收集和分发有关漏洞的宝贵信息。尽管存在预定义的宽泛公告格式,但并未真正标准化。因此,其内容和形式因供应商而异。这使得安全分析师提取相关信息变得繁琐且耗费资源。通用安全公告格式(CSAF)旨在将安全公告纳入标准化格式,以解决现有问题并实现公告的自动化处理。然而,新标准只有在能让用户受益时才有意义。因此问题随之而来:当前状态下的安全公告是否会引起问题?CSAF能够解决其中的哪些问题?自动化的当前状态如何?为了调查这些问题,我们采访了三位安全专家,随后对197名参与者进行了在线调查。结果表明问题确实存在,且通常可追溯到令人困惑和不一致的结构与格式。CSAF试图解决的正是这些问题。然而,我们的结果显示CSAF目前很少被使用。尽管用户认为自动化对于改善安全公告的处理是必要的,但许多人同时也持怀疑态度。主要原因之一是系统尚未为自动化进行设计,且迁移将需要大量资源。

英文摘要:

Security advisories have become an important part of vulnerability management. They can be used to gather and distribute valuable information about vulnerabilities. Although there is a predefined broad format for advisories, it is not really standardized. As a result, their content and form vary greatly depending on the vendor. Thus, it is cumbersome and resource-intensive for security analysts to extract the relevant information. The Common Security Advisory Format (CSAF) aims to bring security advisories into a standardized format which is intended to solve existing problems and to enable automated processing of the advisories. However, a new standard only makes sense if it can benefit users. Hence the questions arise: Do security advisories cause issues in their current state? Which of these issues is CSAF able to resolve? What is the current state of automation? To investigate these questions, we interviewed three security experts, and then conducted an online survey with 197 participants. The results show that problems exist and can often be traced back to confusing and inconsistent structures and formats. CSAF attempts to solve precisely these problems. However, our results show that CSAF is currently rarely used. Although users perceive automation as necessary to improve the processing of security advisories, many are at the same time skeptical. One of the main reasons is that systems are not yet designed for automation and a migration would require vast amounts of resources.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑