arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2408.12795cs.SIcs.MAphysics.soc-ph
收藏

重复且无可辩驳的集体行动失败导致抗议者脱离参与和激进化

Repeated and incontrovertible collective action failure leads to protester disengagement and radicalisation

Emma F. Thomas, Mengbin Ye, Simon D. Angus, Tony J. Mathew, Winnifred Louis, Liam Walsh, Silas Ellery, Morgana Lizzio-Wilson, Craig McGarty

AI总结:

本研究通过约10,000次迭代的智能体模型揭示:当局回应且抗议者可质疑失败时,温和运动占优;当局反复无可辩驳地失败时,人群脱离参与但激进化,形成潜在激进状态,预示突发革命变革。

摘要:

抗议在21世纪无处不在,参与此类运动的人们之所以这样做,是因为他们寻求带来社会变革。然而,社会变革需要时间,并涉及个体抗议者、社会运动以及他们呼吁变革的当局之间的反复互动。这些时间和规模上的复杂性阻碍了人们一方面识别出培育持久运动的条件,另一方面识别出采纳更激进(非常规、不可接受)策略的条件。在此,我们提出一个新颖的、有理论依据且经实证验证的集体行动基于智能体模型,该模型提供了一个统一框架来应对这两个挑战。我们在一个模拟社会中模拟了约10,000次迭代,并表明:当当局反应迅速,且抗议者能够(在认知上和/或社会上)对其运动的失败提出质疑时,一种温和的常规运动将占上风。相反,当当局反复且无可辩驳地使运动失败时,人群会脱离参与但变得激进化(潜在激进主义)。后一发现,即整个人群虽不参与但准备使用激进方法来实现社会变革,可能反映了突发、革命性变革前的狂热前驱状态。结果凸显了模拟在揭示新兴的、尚未理论化的现象方面的潜力。

英文摘要:

Protest is ubiquitous in the 21st Century and the people who participate in such movements do so because they seek to bring about social change. However, social change takes time and involves repeated interactions between individual protesters, social movements and the authorities to whom they appeal for change. These complexities of time and scale have frustrated efforts to isolate the conditions that foster an enduring movement, on the one hand, and the adoption of more radical (unconventional, unacceptable) tactics on the other. Here, we present a novel, theoretically informed and empirically evidenced, agent-based model of collective action that provides a unified framework to address these dual challenges. We model ~10,000 iterations within a simulated society and show that where an authority is responsive, and protesters can (cognitively and/or socially) contest the failure of their movement, a moderate conventional movement prevails. Conversely, where an authority repeatedly and incontrovertibly fails the movement, the population disengages but becomes radicalised (latent radicalism). This latter finding, whereby the whole population is disengaged but prepared to use radical methods to bring about social change, likely reflects the febrile pre-cursor state to sudden, revolutionary change. Results highlight the potential for simulations to reveal emergent, as-yet under-theorized, phenomena.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑