arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2408.11910cs.CYcs.AIcs.HCcs.LG
收藏

为什么我还在看到这个:衡量AI中介广告定向系统中广告控制和解释的有效性

Why am I Still Seeing This: Measuring the Effectiveness Of Ad Controls and Explanations in AI-Mediated Ad Targeting Systems

Princeton University(普林斯顿大学)

Jane Castleman, Aleksandra Korolova

AI总结:

本研究评估Meta转向AI中介定向后“See less”广告控制与定向解释的有效性,发现该控制未能显著减少相关广告且解释缺乏可操作性,表明亟需适应复杂AI广告系统的新透明度与控制方法。

摘要:

最近,Meta已转向不需要广告商提供详细定向标准的AI中介广告定向机制,这可能是出于对AI能力的兴奋,以及新的数据隐私政策和民权和解协议中商定的定向变更。同时,Meta将其广告偏好控制宣传为用户控制所见广告的有效机制。此外,Meta将其定向解释作为透明度工具进行推广,允许用户了解为何看到某些广告,并据此采取行动控制未来的广告。我们的研究评估了在转向AI中介定向后,Meta的“See less”广告控制的有效性以及广告定向解释的可操作性。我们进行了一项大规模研究,随机分配参与者对“Body Weight Control”或“Parenting”主题标记“See less”,并收集干预前后Meta向参与者展示的广告和定向解释。我们发现,针对我们研究的主题使用“See less”广告控制并未显著减少Meta在这些主题上展示的广告数量,且对于某些人口统计特征与该主题相关的用户,该控制效果较差。此外,我们发现大多数本地广告的定向解释未提及特定位置的定向标准,也未告知用户为何与他们标记为“See less”的主题相关的广告仍被持续推送。我们假设,控制和解释缺乏有效性和可操作性是转向AI中介定向的结果,因为尚未为此开发可解释性和透明度工具。因此,我们的工作提供了证据,表明需要新的透明度和用户控制方法,以适应并反映日益复杂的AI中介广告投放系统。

英文摘要:

Recently, Meta has shifted towards AI-mediated ad targeting mechanisms that do not require advertisers to provide detailed targeting criteria, likely driven by excitement over AI capabilities as well as new data privacy policies and targeting changes agreed upon in civil rights settlements. At the same time, Meta has touted their ad preference controls as an effective mechanism for users to control the ads they see. Furthermore, Meta markets their targeting explanations as a transparency tool that allows users to understand why they saw certain ads and inform actions to control future ads. Our study evaluates the effectiveness of Meta's "See less" ad control and the actionability of ad targeting explanations following the shift to AI-mediated targeting. We conduct a large-scale study, randomly assigning participants to mark "See less" to Body Weight Control or Parenting topics, and collecting the ads and targeting explanations Meta shows to participants before and after the intervention. We find that utilizing the "See less" ad control for the topics we study does not significantly reduce the number of ads shown by Meta on these topics, and that the control is less effective for some users whose demographics are correlated with the topic. Furthermore, we find that the majority of ad targeting explanations for local ads made no reference to location-specific targeting criteria, and did not inform users why ads related to the topics they marked to "See less" of continued to be delivered. We hypothesize that the poor effectiveness of controls and lack of actionability in explanations are the result of the shift to AI-mediated targeting, for which explainability and transparency tools have not yet been developed. Our work thus provides evidence for the need of new methods for transparency and user control, suitable and reflective of increasingly complex AI-mediated ad delivery systems.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑