arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2408.06797math.PRcs.AIphysics.soc-ph
收藏

被睡美人震惊:概率王子在二人宿命相遇时如何更新其预测

Stunned by Sleeping Beauty: How Prince Probability updates his forecast upon their fateful encounter

University of York(约克大学);INL – International Iberian Nanotechnology Laboratory(国际伊比利亚纳米技术实验室)

Laurens Walleghem

AI总结:

针对概率论经典的睡美人问题中1/3与1/2的答案争议,研究借助贝叶斯概率论,并引入“概率王子”作为额外观察者辅助论证,证明睡美人醒来时对硬币正面的置信度应为1/3,同时补充了睡美人知晓自己做梦时的置信度分析。

摘要:

睡美人问题是概率论中的一个谜题,自Elga的相关讨论以来受到广泛关注[Elga, Adam, Analysis 60 (2), p.143-147 (2000)]。实验中,睡美人被置入睡眠状态,随后抛掷一枚硬币:若硬币结果为反面(Tails),睡美人会在周一被唤醒,之后再次被置入睡眠,又在周二被唤醒(且她不会记得周一曾被唤醒的经历);若结果为正面(Heads),睡美人仅在周一被唤醒。每次睡美人被唤醒时,都会被问及她认为硬币结果为正面的信念程度是多少,她应该给出怎样的回答?现有文献中,支持1/3和1/2为正确答案的论证均有出现。在这篇短注中,我们运用简单的贝叶斯概率论论证,说明为何正确答案是1/3而非1/2。简言之,当睡美人醒来时,“她处于清醒状态”本身就是一条有价值的额外信息,促使她将对正面结果的信念更新为1/3。我们通过引入额外观察者“概率王子(Prince Probability)”来强化这一论断:王子可能会也可能不会遇到睡美人,若他在睡美人清醒时与其相遇,他会将自己对正面结果的置信度降至1/3。我们还简要探讨了知道自己正在做梦(即处于睡眠状态)的睡美人对正面结果的置信度情况。

英文摘要:

The Sleeping Beauty problem is a puzzle in probability theory that has gained much attention since Elga's discussion of it [Elga, Adam, Analysis 60 (2), p.143-147 (2000)]. Sleeping Beauty is put asleep, and a coin is tossed. If the outcome of the coin toss is Tails, Sleeping Beauty is woken up on Monday, put asleep again and woken up again on Tuesday (with no recollection of having woken up on Monday). If the outcome is Heads, Sleeping Beauty is woken up on Monday only. Each time Sleeping Beauty is woken up, she is asked what her belief is that the outcome was Heads. What should Sleeping Beauty reply? In literature arguments have been given for both 1/3 and 1/2 as the correct answer. In this short note we argue using simple Bayesian probability theory why 1/3 is the right answer, and not 1/2. Briefly, when Sleeping Beauty awakens, her being awake is nontrivial extra information that leads her to update her beliefs about Heads to 1/3. We strengthen our claim by considering an additional observer, Prince Probability, who may or may not meet Sleeping Beauty. If he meets Sleeping Beauty while she is awake, he lowers his credence in Heads to 1/3. We also briefly consider the credence in Heads of a Sleeping Beauty who knows that she is dreaming (and thus asleep).

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑