arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2408.06546cs.HC
收藏

与AI的适配失调:盲人如何验证和质疑AI错误

Misfitting With AI: How Blind People Verify and Contest AI Errors

Rahaf Alharbi, Pa Lor, Jaylin Herskovitz, Sarita Schoenebeck, Robin Brewer

AI总结:

该研究通过对26名盲人的定性研究,探究其验证AI视觉辅助技术错误的方式与需求,基于残疾研究框架剖析相关问题,提出无障碍可解释AI的设计方向与负责任AI实践建议。

摘要:

盲人使用人工智能赋能的视觉辅助技术(AI VAT)在日常生活中获取视觉信息,但这类技术存在的错误可能难以通过非视觉方式验证。以往研究主要探讨了有视力用户对AI输出的理解,并构建了依赖视觉的可解释人工智能(XAI)功能。我们通过对26名盲人开展深度定性研究拓展了相关文献,以了解他们的验证体验与偏好。我们首先描述了盲人遇到的错误,强调AI VAT在支持复杂文档版式、多语言及文化器物方面的不足。随后阐明了盲人如何通过试用AI VAT、运用非视觉技能、策略性地求助有视力的人以及与其他设备交叉验证来理解AI。参与者提出了设计无障碍XAI的具体方向,例如支持质疑操作的可供性。基于残疾研究中的“适配失调与适配”框架,我们剖析了AI VAT背后的有害假设,强调了重视残障认知方式的重要性。最后,我们为负责任AI实践提供了可行建议,以推动无障碍XAI领域的发展。

英文摘要:

Blind people use artificial intelligence-enabled visual assistance technologies (AI VAT) to gain visual access in their everyday lives, but these technologies are embedded with errors that may be difficult to verify non-visually. Previous studies have primarily explored sighted users' understanding of AI output and created vision-dependent explainable AI (XAI) features. We extend this body of literature by conducting an in-depth qualitative study with 26 blind people to understand their verification experiences and preferences. We begin by describing errors blind people encounter, highlighting how AI VAT fails to support complex document layouts, diverse languages, and cultural artifacts. We then illuminate how blind people make sense of AI through experimenting with AI VAT, employing non-visual skills, strategically including sighted people, and cross-referencing with other devices. Participants provided detailed opportunities for designing accessible XAI, such as affordances to support contestation. Informed by disability studies framework of misfitting and fitting, we unpacked harmful assumptions with AI VAT, underscoring the importance of celebrating disabled ways of knowing. Lastly, we offer practical takeaways for Responsible AI practice to push the field of accessible XAI forward.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑