发明人-评审人网络中的高影响力创新与隐性性别差距
High-Impact Innovations and Hidden Gender Disparities in Inventor-Evaluator Networks
AI总结:
该研究基于数百万项创新数据发现,女性创新差距主要集中于高影响力的非传统创新,其根源在于USPTO的制度性实践而非性别歧视,并指出这些制度障碍更易通过政策改革解决。
摘要:
我们研究了数百万项科学、技术和艺术创新,发现女性面临的创新差距远非普遍存在。对于常规创新而言,并不存在差距。相反,这种差距普遍根植于那些以意想不到的方式组合思想的创新之中——而这些创新恰恰对科学突破最为关键。此外,在美国专利商标局(USPTO),我们发现女性审查员驳回女性发明人的非传统创新的比例比男性审查员高出多达33%,这表明性别歧视只能微弱地解释这一创新差距。相反,新的数据表明,一系列制度性实践的组合解释了这一创新差距。这些实践削弱了女性审查员准确评估非传统创新所需的专业知识,然后将女性审查员“过度分配”给女性创新者,从而损害了女性的创新。这些制度性障碍对科学领域的创新率产生了负面影响,但与文化上根深蒂固的性别歧视相比,其优点在于更容易通过可操作的政策变革加以改善。
英文摘要:
We study of millions of scientific, technological, and artistic innovations and find that the innovation gap faced by women is far from universal. No gap exists for conventional innovations. Rather, the gap is pervasively rooted in innovations that combine ideas in unexpected ways - innovations most critical to scientific breakthroughs. Further, at the USPTO we find that female examiners reject up to 33 percent more unconventional innovations by women inventors than do male examiners, suggesting that gender discrimination weakly explains this innovation gap. Instead, new data indicate that a configuration of institutional practices explains the innovation gap. These practices compromise the expertise women examiners need to accurately assess unconventional innovations and then "over-assign" women examiners to women innovators, undermining women's innovations. These institutional impediments negatively impact innovation rates in science but have the virtue of being more amenable to actionable policy changes than does culturally ingrained gender discrimination.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。