承诺升级:美国人口普查局为2020年十年一次的人口普查实施差分隐私的努力案例研究
Escalation of Commitment: A Case Study of the United States Census Bureau Efforts to Implement Differential Privacy for the 2020 Decennial Census
AI总结:
本研究评估了美国人口普查局2010年人口普查数据的披露风险声明,发现其风险评估程序不可靠且导致风险被夸大,指出人口普查局因承诺升级而实施的差分隐私机制未能兼顾2020年数据的隐私与准确性。
摘要:
2017年,美国人口普查局宣布,由于用于生成2010年人口普查表格数据的方法(数据交换)存在高披露风险,2020年人口普查将使用基于差分隐私的不同保护机制。尽管有许多研究评估了这一变更的结果,但尚未对已发布的2010年表格数据所产生的披露风险声明进行严格审查。在本研究中,我们执行了这样的评估。我们表明,用于评估披露风险的程序是不可靠的,并导致了夸大的披露风险。使用新程序发布的演示数据产品也被证明效用不佳。然而,由于人口普查局已经承诺采用不同的程序,他们除了升级其承诺外别无选择。这种升级的结果是,2020年表格数据发布既没有提供隐私也没有提供准确性。
英文摘要:
In 2017, the United States Census Bureau announced that because of high disclosure risk in the methodology (data swapping) used to produce tabular data for the 2010 census, a different protection mechanism based on differential privacy would be used for the 2020 census. While there have been many studies evaluating the result of this change, there has been no rigorous examination of disclosure risk claims resulting from the released 2010 tabular data. In this study we perform such an evaluation. We show that the procedures used to evaluate disclosure risk are unreliable and resulted in inflated disclosure risk. Demonstration data products released using the new procedure were also shown to have poor utility. However, since the Census Bureau had already committed to a different procedure, they had no option except to escalate their commitment. The result of such escalation is that the 2020 tabular data release offers neither privacy nor accuracy.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。