用于生成匹配利益相关者需求的能源系统设计方案的人在回路 MGA
Human-in-the-loop MGA to generate energy system design options matching stakeholder needs
AI总结:
针对 MGA 难以生成契合利益相关者需求方案的问题,提出 HITL-MGA,通过交互式偏好获取与解码引导搜索,并在葡萄牙能源系统合成实验中验证其促进共识的潜力。
摘要:
普遍使用成本最小化来支持能源系统设计决策,掩盖了许多在经济上可比且可能受到利益相关者青睐的设计方案。建模以生成替代方案(MGA)作为超越最低成本设计的方法正日益普及,可为利益相关者提供多样化的投资组合以供评估。然而,生成所有可行设计在计算上并不可行;建模者必须选择围绕哪些设计特征生成多样性,尽管他们并不知道哪些权衡在实践中最重要。因此,仅凭 MGA 无法确保生成匹配利益相关者需求的设计方案。为弥补这一不足,我们提出一种人在回路(HITL)方法,将利益相关者偏好自动整合到 MGA 中。我们通过让利益相关者与初步的 MGA 设计空间交互来获取偏好。随后,我们解码这些偏好,将其反馈给 MGA 算法并执行引导搜索。该搜索生成一个经人工训练的设计空间,其中包含更多反映所获取偏好的设计。一项针对葡萄牙能源系统的合成实验表明,HITL-MGA 可能促进共识形成,有望加速在技术和社会层面均可行的能源转型决策。
英文摘要:
The common use of cost minimisation to support energy system design decisions hides from view many economically comparable design options that stakeholders may prefer. Modelling to generate alternatives (MGA) is increasingly popular as a way to go beyond least-cost designs, providing stakeholders with diverse portfolios to appraise. However, generating all the feasible designs is not computationally viable; modellers must choose what design features to generate diversity around, despite not knowing which trade-offs matter the most in practice. Therefore, MGA alone cannot ensure the generation of design options that match stakeholder needs. To address this shortcoming, we propose a human-in-the-loop (HITL) approach that automatically integrates stakeholder preferences into MGA. We elicit preferences by letting stakeholders interact with a tentative MGA design space. Hence, we decode those preferences to feed them back to the MGA algorithm and perform a guided search. This search produces a human-trained design space with more designs that mirror the elicited preferences. A synthetic experiment for the Portuguese energy system shows that HITL-MGA may facilitate consensus formation, promising to accelerate technically and socially feasible energy transition decisions.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。