arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2407.10938physics.bio-phq-bio.QM
收藏

空间随机系统基于模拟的推断中AI工作流与优化工作流的比较

Comparing AI versus Optimization Workflows for Simulation-Based Inference of Spatial-Stochastic Systems

Michael A. Ramirez-Sierra, Thomas R. Sokolowski

AI总结:

本研究对比了基于深度学习的SNPE与经典模拟退火SA两种SBI工作流,在小鼠ICM谱系分化模型上验证发现同等计算成本下现代SBI推断分布更丰富,并提出二者整合方案以协同探索参数空间。

摘要:

模型参数推断是横跨科学领域的共性问题。这一挑战在发育生物学中尤为突出:忠实的机制描述需要包含大量参数的空间随机模型,但受实验限制,定量经验数据往往缺乏足够的粒度。因此,为这类复杂模型定参需要在经典贝叶斯推断基础上拓展的方法,通过低维目标函数引入最优性和目标导向的概念,以定量捕捉底层系统的目标行为。\n本研究对比了两种此类推断工作流,并将其应用于受生物物理学启发的空间随机模型。从技术层面看,两种工作流均属于基于模拟的推断(SBI)方法。第一种方法利用名为序列神经后验估计(SNPE)的现代深度学习技术,第二种则基于称为模拟退火(SA)的经典优化技术。\n我们通过推断囊胚期小鼠胚胎内细胞团(ICM)谱系分化的两个互补模型的参数,对这些工作流进行评估。该发育生物学系统是高度鲁棒且可复现的细胞命运配比过程的典型范例,该过程在强随机条件(如内源性生化噪声和细胞间信号延迟)下自组织。\n结果表明,尽管两种方法的预测结果大体一致,但现代SBI工作流在相同计算成本下能提供丰富得多的推断分布。我们明确了更适合采用现代SBI方法而非经典方法的计算场景。最后,我们提出了一种整合这两种方法的可行思路,以协同利用二者的参数空间探索能力。

英文摘要:

Model parameter inference is a universal problem across science. This challenge is particularly pronounced in developmental biology, where faithful mechanistic descriptions require spatial-stochastic models with numerous parameters, yet quantitative empirical data often lack sufficient granularity due to experimental limitations. Parameterizing such complex models thus necessitates methods that elaborate on classical Bayesian inference by incorporating notions of optimality and goal-orientation through low-dimensional objective functions that quantitatively capture the target behavior of the underlying system. In this study, we contrast two such inference workflows and apply them to biophysics-inspired spatial-stochastic models. Technically, both workflows are simulation-based inference (SBI) methods. The first method leverages a modern deep-learning technique known as sequential neural posterior estimation (SNPE), while the second is based on a classical optimization technique called simulated annealing (SA). We evaluate these workflows by inferring the parameters of two complementary models for the inner cell mass (ICM) lineage differentiation in the blastocyst-stage mouse embryo. This developmental biology system serves as a paradigmatic example of a highly robust and reproducible cell-fate proportioning process that self-organizes under strongly stochastic conditions, such as intrinsic biochemical noise and cell-cell signaling delays. Our results indicate that while both methods largely agree in their predictions, the modern SBI workflow provides substantially richer inferred distributions at an equivalent computational cost. We identify the computational scenarios that favor the modern SBI method over its classical counterpart. Finally, we propose a plausible approach to integrate these two methods, thereby synergistically exploiting their parameter space exploration capabilities.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑