利用贝叶斯定理调和基于风险的归因与情景线归因
Reconciling risk-based and storyline attribution with Bayes theorem
AI总结:
本研究针对极端事件归因中基于风险的无条件方法与情景线条件方法的差异,利用贝叶斯定理建立二者关联,并通过模型与真实案例验证了条件设定对归因结论强弱的影响。
摘要:
气候变化在多大程度上导致了极端天气事件,多年来一直是公众和学术界讨论的焦点。“基于风险”的归因方法的支持者试图根据存在人类影响和不存在人类影响的世界中某类事件的发生概率,给出一个无条件的答案。作为替代方案,所谓的“情景线(storyline)”研究则探究更温暖的世界对单个特定天气事件的影响,这可被视为一种条件归因表述。本研究利用贝叶斯定理将条件归因与无条件归因关联起来:本质上,条件表述由两个无条件表述组成,一个基于所有可用数据(事件及条件),另一个仅基于条件本身。我们在一个简单的统计玩具模型,以及以阻塞(blocking)为条件的欧洲夏季温度真实归因案例中,探究了条件设定带来的影响。若条件不受气候变化影响,最终得到的归因表述通常会更强;反之,若部分趋势包含在条件之中,则可能得到更弱的归因表述。
英文摘要:
The question to what extent climate change is responsible for extreme weather events has been at the forefront of public and scholarly discussion for years. Proponents of the "risk-based" approach to attribution attempt to give an unconditional answer based on the probability of some class of events in a world with and without human influences. As an alternative, so-called "storyline" studies investigate the impact of a warmer world on a single, specific weather event. This can be seen as a conditional attribution statement. In this study, we connect conditional to unconditional attribution using Bayes theorem: in essence, the conditional statement is composed of two unconditional statements, one based on all available data (event and conditions) and one based on the conditions alone. We explore the effects of the conditioning in a simple statistical toy model and a real-world attribution of European summer temperatures conditional on blocking. The resulting attribution statement is generally strengthened if the conditions are not affected by climate change. Conversely, if part of the trend is contained in the conditions, a weaker attribution statement may result.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。