建模选择对连通性估计的影响:一项比较分析
Implication of modelling choices on connectivity estimation: A comparative analysis
AI总结:
该研究比较了两种景观表征方法和三种运动模型,发现景观表征是决定连通性估计的主要因素,整合随机与行为过程的方法更现实。
摘要:
景观连通性是一个重要的领域,具有重要的保护意义。连通性建模是指导和规划景观的有用工具。然而,它涉及假设和方法决策,这些最终会影响连通性结果。为了理解建模选择对最终连通性估计的影响,我们比较了两种景观表征方法——专家知识和物种分布模型——以及三种运动模型——最小成本路径、电路理论和基于个体的运动模拟器。模型的实施和分析范围的构建突出了概念和方法上的差异,这使得比较变得困难。景观表征似乎是决定连通性结果的主要因素。因此,专家知识与物种分布模型之间的对比对于利用这两种方法之间的收敛点和互补性至关重要。运动模型之间的概念差异在连通性地图和栖息地斑块贡献估计中有所报告。在缺乏专门用于验证连通性模型的数据和协议设计的情况下,整合随机和行为过程的方法为连通性估计带来了更现实的视角。
英文摘要:
Landscape connectivity is an important field with important conservation implications. Connectivity modelling is a useful tool to inform and guide landscape planning. However, it involves assumptions and methodological decisions which ultimately impact connectivity outcomes. In order to understand the implications of modelling choices on final connectivity estimations, we compare two landscape characterisation approaches - expert knowledge and species distribution models - and three movements models - least-cost paths, circuit theory and an individual-based movement simulator. The implementation of the models and the construction of the analyses scope highlighted conceptual and methodological differences that made the comparison difficult. Landscape characterisation appears as the principal factor determining connectivity outcomes. Therefore, the confrontation between expert knowledge and species distribution models is critical to leverage points of convergence and complementarity between these two approaches. Conceptual differences between movement models are reported on connectivity map and habitat patch contribution estimations. In the want of data and protocol design specifically to validate connectivity models, approaches that integrate stochastic and behavioural processes, bring a more realistic perspective to connectivity estimation.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。