arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2407.05341cs.CYcs.AI
收藏

开关、阶梯与矩阵:AI系统分类模型

The Switch, the Ladder, and the Matrix: Models for Classifying AI Systems

Oxford Internet Institute, University of Oxford(牛津大学牛津互联网研究院);R&D Data Office, AstraZeneca PLC(阿斯利康制药研发数据办公室);Department of Statistical Science, University College London(伦敦大学学院统计科学系);Department of Legal Studies, University of Bologna(博洛尼亚大学法律研究系)

Jakob Mokander, Margi Sheth, David Watson, Luciano Floridi

AI总结:

本文梳理AI伦理落地中适用范围不清的问题,比较“开关”“阶梯”“矩阵”三种AI系统分类心智模型,为组织实践AI治理提供概念工具。

摘要:

设计和部署人工智能(AI)系统的组织越来越多地承诺遵循高层级的伦理原则。然而,AI伦理中的原则与实践之间仍然存在差距。各组织在尝试将AI伦理操作化时面临的一个主要障碍,是缺乏界定清晰的实质适用范围。换言之,AI伦理原则应当适用于哪些系统和流程,这一问题仍未得到解答。当然,目前并不存在被普遍接受的AI定义,而且不同系统会带来不同的伦理挑战。尽管如此,务实的问题解决要求对事物进行分类,使其分组能够促进为某种特定目的而采取成功行动。在本文中,我们回顾并比较了以往为在实践中实施AI治理而对AI系统进行分类的尝试。我们发现,以往文献中对AI系统进行分类的尝试使用了三种心智模型之一。“开关”(The Switch),即一种二元方法,根据系统的特征将其要么视为AI系统、要么不视为AI系统。“阶梯”(The Ladder),即一种基于风险的方法,根据系统所构成的伦理风险对其进行分类。“矩阵”(The Matrix),即对系统进行多维度分类,考虑情境、数据输入和决策模型等多个方面。这些用于分类AI系统的模型各有其优缺点。通过将不同的AI系统分类方式概念化为简单的心智模型,我们希望为设计、部署或监管AI系统的组织提供在实践中将AI治理操作化所需的概念工具。

英文摘要:

Organisations that design and deploy artificial intelligence (AI) systems increasingly commit themselves to high-level, ethical principles. However, there still exists a gap between principles and practices in AI ethics. One major obstacle organisations face when attempting to operationalise AI Ethics is the lack of a well-defined material scope. Put differently, the question to which systems and processes AI ethics principles ought to apply remains unanswered. Of course, there exists no universally accepted definition of AI, and different systems pose different ethical challenges. Nevertheless, pragmatic problem-solving demands that things should be sorted so that their grouping will promote successful actions for some specific end. In this article, we review and compare previous attempts to classify AI systems for the purpose of implementing AI governance in practice. We find that attempts to classify AI systems found in previous literature use one of three mental model. The Switch, i.e., a binary approach according to which systems either are or are not considered AI systems depending on their characteristics. The Ladder, i.e., a risk-based approach that classifies systems according to the ethical risks they pose. And the Matrix, i.e., a multi-dimensional classification of systems that take various aspects into account, such as context, data input, and decision-model. Each of these models for classifying AI systems comes with its own set of strengths and weaknesses. By conceptualising different ways of classifying AI systems into simple mental models, we hope to provide organisations that design, deploy, or regulate AI systems with the conceptual tools needed to operationalise AI governance in practice.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑