谁的知识被重视?:CSCW应用中的认知不公正
Whose Knowledge is Valued?: Epistemic Injustice in CSCW Applications
AI总结:
本文通过14位CSCW实践者的协作式自民族志研究,揭示社会技术应用中的认知不公正现象及其危害,并提出以个体经验为中心、增强社区力量和纠正认知权力三项行动倡议,推动CSCW领域实现研究公正。
摘要:
社会计算学者早已认识到,人们与知识的互动方式并不简单直接,尤其是在数字环境中。虽然围绕知识的政策对于应对错误信息至关重要,但这些政策本身承载着价值取向;在选择如何呈现信息时,我们削弱了非传统的——往往是非西方的——认知方式。认知不公正是指某些人群及其认知方法被系统性地排除在知识经典之外。认知不公正会逐步侵蚀一个人的证言和表达词汇,直到他们被剥夺了应有的知情权和理解权。在本文中,我们阐述了社会技术应用中的认知不公正如何导致实质性伤害。受14位CSCW实践者参与的混合协作式自民族志研究启发,我们呈现了社会技术应用中三个认知不公正的案例:在线跨性别医疗保健、r/bisexual上的身份意义建构,以及r/AskHistorians上的原住民认知方式。我们进一步探讨了自民族志材料中反复出现的标志性张力,并将其与此前的CSCW研究领域以及个人非技术经历联系起来。我们认为,认知不公正可以通过揭示认知共同体与权力的维度,为CSCW研究提供一个统一且具有交叉性视角的分析框架。最后,我们提出行动呼吁,指出CSCW社区应当做出三项改变,以朝着自身的研究公正目标迈进。我们呼吁CSCW研究者以个体经验为中心,增强社区力量,并纠正认知权力方面的问题,以此作为实现认知公正的途径。总而言之,我们记述、综合并提出了针对CSCW研究场域——包括CSCW自身——所传播的各种形式的认知不公正的解决方案。
英文摘要:
Social computing scholars have long known that people do not interact with knowledge in straightforward ways, especially in digital environments. While policies around knowledge are essential for targeting misinformation, they are value-laden; in choosing how to present information, we undermine non-traditional -- often non-Western -- ways of knowing. Epistemic injustice is the systemic exclusion of certain people and methods from the knowledge canon. Epistemic injustice chips away at one's testimony and vocabulary until they are stripped of their due right to know and understand. In this paper, we articulate how epistemic injustice in sociotechnical applications leads to material harm. Inspired by a hybrid collaborative autoethnography of 14 CSCW practitioners, we present three cases of epistemic injustice in sociotechnical applications: online transgender healthcare, identity sensemaking on r/bisexual, and Indigenous ways of knowing on r/AskHistorians. We further explore signature tensions across our autoethnographic materials and relate them to previous CSCW research areas and personal non-technological experiences. We argue that epistemic injustice can serve as a unifying and intersectional lens for CSCW research by surfacing dimensions of epistemic community and power. Finally, we present a call to action of three changes the CSCW community should make to move toward its own goals of research justice. We call for CSCW researchers to center individual experiences, bolster communities, and remediate issues of epistemic power as a means towards epistemic justice. In sum, we recount, synthesize, and propose solutions for the various forms of epistemic injustice that CSCW sites of study -- including CSCW itself -- propagate.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。