背景:随着晚期疾病患者接近生命终点,不良结局事件的发生率会上升。因此,那些往往在临终前发生的暴露,例如轮椅使用、氧疗和姑息治疗,可能会被发现与不良结局的发生率相关。我们提出一种用于事件发生时间分析的策略,以缓解这种时变混杂。方法:我们提出反向死亡时间(rTTD)的概念,并将其用作事件发生时间分析中的时间尺度。我们使用新加坡晚期癌症患者中社区姑息治疗接受情况(暴露)和急诊科就诊(结局)的数据进行说明。我们将结果与使用研究时间(TOS)作为时间尺度的常见做法进行比较。结果:图形分析表明,接受姑息治疗的癌症患者急诊科就诊率高于未接受者,主要是因为他们更接近生命终点;而 rTTD 分析能够在相同的死亡时间点上对患者进行比较。使用 TOS 时间尺度分析急诊科就诊与姑息治疗的关系时,当统计调整中省略已观测的时变协变量后,风险比估计值出现显著增加(估计值变化=0.38;95% CI 0.15 至 0.60)。而在其他方面相同的分析中,使用 rTTD 时未出现此类变化(估计值变化=0.04;95% CI -0.02 至 0.11),表明 rTTD 时间尺度能够缓解随死亡时间而增强的混杂。结论:在事件发生时间分析中使用 rTTD 作为时间尺度,为晚期疾病研究中的时变混杂控制提供了一种简单且稳健的方法,即使混杂因素未被测量也是如此。
英文摘要:
Background: Incidence of adverse outcome events rises as patients with advanced illness approach end-of-life. Exposures that tend to occur near end-of-life, e.g., use of wheelchair, oxygen therapy and palliative care, may therefore be found associated with the incidence of the adverse outcomes. We propose a strategy for time-to-event analysis to mitigate the time-varying confounding. Methods: We propose a concept of reverse time-to-death (rTTD) and its use for the time-scale in time-to-event analysis. We used data on community-based palliative care uptake (exposure) and emergency department visits (outcome) among patients with advanced cancer in Singapore to illustrate. We compare the results against that of the common practice of using time-on-study (TOS) as time-scale. Results: Graphical analysis demonstrated that cancer patients receiving palliative care had higher rate of emergency department visits than non-recipients mainly because they were closer to end-of-life, and that rTTD analysis made comparison between patients at the same time-to-death. Analysis of emergency department visits in relation to palliative care using TOS time-scale showed significant increase in hazard ratio estimate when observed time-varying covariates were omitted from statistical adjustment (change-in-estimate=0.38; 95% CI 0.15 to 0.60). There was no such change in otherwise the same analysis using rTTD (change-in-estimate=0.04; 95% CI -0.02 to 0.11), demonstrating the ability of rTTD time-scale to mitigate confounding that intensifies in relation to time-to-death. Conclusion: Use of rTTD as time-scale in time-to-event analysis provides a simple and robust approach to control time-varying confounding in studies of advanced illness, even if the confounders are unmeasured.
Discrimination performance in illness-death models with interval-censored disease data
Mathematical Institute, Leiden University(莱顿大学数学研究所);Department of Biomedical Data Sciences, Leiden University Medical Center(莱顿大学医学中心生物医学数据科学系);Trial and Data Center, Princess Máxima Center for Pediatric Oncology(公主玛克西玛儿童肿瘤中心试验与数据中心)
Randomization inference for stepped-wedge designs with noncompliance with application to a palliative care pragmatic trial
University of Chicago(芝加哥大学);Data Science Institute, University of Chicago(芝加哥大学数据科学研究所);University of Pennsylvania(宾夕法尼亚大学);Department of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania(宾夕法尼亚大学医学系);Department of Mathematics and Statistics, Mississippi State University(密西西比州立大学数学与统计系);Department of Statistics and Data Science, University of Pennsylvania(宾夕法尼亚大学统计与数据科学系);Yale School of Public Health(耶鲁公共卫生学院)
A new stochastic differential equation modelling incidence and prevalence with an application to systemic lupus erythematosus in England and Wales, 1995
Maximum likelihood estimation for aggregate current status data: Simulation study using the illness-death model for chronic diseases with duration dependency