arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2407.01968cs.CY
收藏

悬而未决的法律:是时候产生新方法了吗?

Unsettled Law: Time to Generate New Approaches?

David Atkinson, Jacob Morrison

AI总结:

本文识别了生成式人工智能引发的独特且悬而未决的法律问题,质疑既有法律框架的充分性,并围绕版权、隐私、侵权、合同、刑法、财产及第一修正案等领域探讨法律与监管适应方向,以推动前瞻性政策讨论。

摘要:

我们识别出若干由生成式人工智能(GenAI)引发的、具有深远伦理与社会影响的重要且悬而未决的法律问题,重点关注其区别于传统软件和早期人工智能模型的特征。我们的核心贡献在于正式识别出GenAI所独有的问题,以便学者、从业者及其他人士能够开展更有用的调查与讨论。虽然现行法律框架——其中许多起源于前数字时代——目前正被用于GenAI诉讼,但我们对其充分性提出质疑。我们认为,GenAI的独特属性,包括其通用性、对海量数据集的依赖,以及可能同时带来广泛社会利益与危害的潜力,都要求对现有法律范式进行重新评估。我们探索了法律与监管适应的潜在领域,重点强调围绕版权、隐私、侵权法、合同法、刑法、财产法以及美国宪法第一修正案的关键问题。通过对这些多层面法律挑战的探讨,我们旨在激发围绕GenAI的讨论与政策考量,强调对法律与伦理框架采取积极主动的方法。虽然我们不主张具体的法律修改,但我们强调政策制定者有必要认真考虑所提出的问题。最后,我们以一张便于查阅的表格总结了上述法律领域中的关键问题。

英文摘要:

We identify several important and unsettled legal questions with profound ethical and societal implications arising from generative artificial intelligence (GenAI), focusing on its distinguishable characteristics from traditional software and earlier AI models. Our key contribution is formally identifying the issues that are unique to GenAI so scholars, practitioners, and others can conduct more useful investigations and discussions. While established legal frameworks, many originating from the pre-digital era, are currently employed in GenAI litigation, we question their adequacy. We argue that GenAI's unique attributes, including its general-purpose nature, reliance on massive datasets, and potential for both pervasive societal benefits and harms, necessitate a re-evaluation of existing legal paradigms. We explore potential areas for legal and regulatory adaptation, highlighting key issues around copyright, privacy, torts, contract law, criminal law, property law, and the First Amendment. Through an exploration of these multifaceted legal challenges, we aim to stimulate discourse and policy considerations surrounding GenAI, emphasizing a proactive approach to legal and ethical frameworks. While we refrain from advocating specific legal changes, we underscore the need for policymakers to carefully consider the issues raised. We conclude by summarizing key questions across these areas of law in a helpful table for easy reference.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑