arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2406.17872cs.HC
收藏

2023年美国交通事故原因分析:评估人们对数据可视化的理解

Analysis of the Causes of Car Accidents in the United States of America in 2023: Gauge People Understanding of Data Visualisation

Hamoud Alhazmi, Marcelo Morales, Jiachen Jiang, Jinxin Zhou, Jian Chen

AI总结:

本文通过开发交互式热力图、直方图和饼图等可视化工具分析2023年美国交通事故数据,并通过在线调查评估了这些工具在静态与交互模式下的有效性,发现交互式可视化的效果因数据类型和复杂性而异。

摘要:

本文对交互式数据可视化工具及其在2023年美国交通事故数据背景下的有效性进行了全面检验。我们开发了交互式热力图、直方图和饼图,以增强对随时间和地点变化的事故严重程度分布的理解。我们的研究包括创建并分发一份在线调查,该调查由九个问题组成,旨在测试参与者对所呈现数据的理解能力。我们招募了十五名受访者完成该调查,目的是评估每种可视化工具的静态和交互版本的有效性。结果表明,与使用直方图和饼图的参与者相比,使用交互式热力图的参与者对数据表现出更深的理解。相比之下,在使用静态和交互式直方图的用户之间没有观察到理解能力的显著差异。出乎意料的是,静态饼图被发现比其交互式版本略为有效。这些发现表明,尽管交互式可视化可能很强大,但其实用性可能会根据所呈现数据的类型和复杂性而有所不同。建议未来的研究探索社会经济因素对理解交通事故数据的影响,从而有可能带来更具针对性和更有效的可视化策略。这可以为交通事故的模式和原因提供更深入的见解,从而促进利益相关者做出更明智的决策。访问我们的网站以探索我们的交互式图表,并直接与数据进行互动,以更全面地理解我们的发现。

英文摘要:

This paper presents a comprehensive examination of interactive data visualization tools and their efficacy in the context of United States car accident data for the year 2023. We developed interactive heatmaps, histograms, and pie charts to enhance the understanding of accident severity distribution over time and location. Our research included the creation and distribution of an online survey, consisting of nine questions designed to test participants comprehension of the presented data. Fifteen respondents were recruited to complete the survey, with the intent of assessing the effectiveness of both static and interactive versions of each visualization tool. The results indicated that participants using interactive heatmaps showed a greater understanding of the data, as compared to those using histograms and pie charts. In contrast, no notable difference in comprehension was observed between users of static and interactive histograms. Unexpectedly, static pie charts were found to be slightly more effective than their interactive counterparts. These findings suggest that while interactive visualizations can be powerful, their utility may vary depending on the type and complexity of the data presented. Future research is recommended to explore the influence of socioeconomic factors on the understanding of car accident data, potentially leading to more tailored and effective visualization strategies. This could provide deeper insights into the patterns and causes of car accidents, facilitating better-informed decision-making for stakeholders. Visit our website to explore our interactive plots and engage directly with the data for a more comprehensive understanding of our findings.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑