网络荟萃分析中评估不一致性的“设计”影响分析
Influence analyses of "designs" for evaluating inconsistency in network meta-analysis
AI总结:
本文提出基于影响诊断的框架,通过四种新方法和O值量化单个设计对网络荟萃分析结果的影响,以评估不一致性并定位潜在来源。
摘要:
网络荟萃分析是一种用于比较多种可用治疗方案有效性的证据合成方法。为了证明证据合成的合理性,一致性是一个重要的假设;然而,现有的基于统计检验的方法在处理多臂研究时,可能在统计功效上受到显著限制,或存在若干缺陷。此外,不一致性在理论上可以被解释为设计-处理交互作用,此类分析的主要目的是优先考虑对特定“设计”的进一步调查,以探索可能影响整体结果的偏倚来源及其他问题。在本文中,我们提出了一种使用影响诊断方法评估不一致性的替代框架,该方法能够定量评估单个设计对整体结果的影响。我们提供了四种新方法:平均学生化残差、MDFFITS、Φ_d和Ξ_d,通过“留一设计”分析框架来量化单个设计的影响。我们还提出了一种简单的汇总度量——O值,用于对设计进行优先级排序并以直接的方式解释这些有影响的分析。此外,我们基于“留一设计”分析框架提出了另一种检验方法。通过将新方法应用于抗高血压药物的网络荟萃分析并进行模拟研究,我们证明了新方法能够准确定位潜在的不一致性来源。所提出的方法为现有基于检验的方法提供了新的替代见解,特别是在量化单个设计对整体网络荟萃分析结果的影响方面。
英文摘要:
Network meta-analysis is an evidence synthesis method for comparing the effectiveness of multiple available treatments. To justify evidence synthesis, consistency is an important assumption; however, existing methods founded on statistical testing can be substantially limited in statistical power or have several drawbacks when handling multi-arm studies. Moreover, inconsistency can be theoretically explained as design-by-treatment interactions, and the primary purpose of such analyses is to prioritize the further investigation of specific "designs" to explore sources of bias and other issues that might influence the overall results. In this article, we propose an alternative framework for evaluating inconsistency using influence diagnostics methods, which enable the influence of individual designs on the overall results to be quantitatively evaluated. We provide four new methods, the averaged studentized residual, MDFFITS, Φ_d, and Ξ_d, to quantify the influence of individual designs through a "leave-one-design-out" analysis framework. We also propose a simple summary measure, the O-value, for prioritizing designs and interpreting these influential analyses in a straightforward manner. Furthermore, we propose another testing approach based on the leave-one-design-out analysis framework. By applying the new methods to a network meta-analysis of antihypertensive drugs and performing simulation studies, we demonstrate that the new methods accurately located potential sources of inconsistency. The proposed methods provide new insights into alternatives to existing test-based methods, especially the quantification of the influence of individual designs on the overall network meta-analysis results.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。