arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2406.15215cs.CRcs.CYecon.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

喧嚣与骚动,毫无意义?数据泄露披露法规的影响

Sound and Fury, Signifying Nothing? Impact of Data Breach Disclosure Laws

Muhammad Zia Hydari, Yangfan Liang, Rahul Telang

AI总结:

该研究针对数据泄露披露法规能通过客户抵制带来收入损失、从而倒逼企业改善网络安全的假定,以美国某零售商大规模数据泄露为样本用双重差分法分析,未发现收入下降证据,质疑了这类法规的实际效用。

摘要:

数据泄露披露(DBD)被认为能通过引发企业对后续收入损失的担忧,改善其网络安全实践。该理论认为,若客户通过拒绝购买来惩罚违规企业,就会产生这种收入损失,且这被视为DBD法规能事前改变企业行为的核心机制。然而,我们对美国某零售商的大规模数据泄露事件的分析,未发现收入下降的证据。我们采用双重差分设计,基于泄露披露前后20周内302家门店的收入数据展开研究,结果显示,无论是全门店样本,还是按此前收入规模进行子抽样(以控制此前收入规模的异质性),均无收入下降的证据。因此我们认为,DBD法规所假定的核心作用机制并不成立,这类法规可能并无实效,不过是一场“喧嚣与骚动,毫无意义”。

英文摘要:

Data breach disclosure (DBD) is presumed to improve firms' cybersecurity practices by inducing fear of subsequent revenue loss. This revenue loss, the theory goes, will occur if customers punish an offending firm by refusing to buy from them and is assumed to be the primary mechanism through which DBD laws will change firm behavior ex ante. However, our analysis of a large-scale data breach at a US retailer reveals no evidence of a decline in revenue. Using a difference-in-difference design on revenue data from 302 stores over a 20-week period around the breach disclosure, we found no evidence of a decline either across all stores or when sub-sampling by prior revenue size (to account for any heterogeneity in prior revenue size). Therefore, we posit that the presumed primary mechanism of DBD laws, and thus these laws may be ineffective and merely a lot of "sound and fury, signifying nothing."

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑