arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2406.12167cs.CYmath.COphysics.soc-ph
收藏

界限与漏洞:检测党派不公正划分选区的对称性度量的局限性

Bounds and Bugs: The Limits of Symmetry Metrics to Detect Partisan Gerrymandering

Daryl DeFord, Ellen Veomett

AI总结:

本文分析了均值-中位数差异和党派偏差两种对称性度量在检测党派不公正划分选区时的局限性,通过理论与实证研究证明其在18张美国地图上可能无法检测出极端席位结果。

摘要:

我们考虑了两种常用于分析党派不公正划分选区的对称性度量:均值-中位数差异(MM)和党派偏差(PB)。我们的主要结果针对在选区选举中可实现的席位与选票组合,将各党派赢得的选区数量与偏离理想度量值的潜在程度进行了比较,并考虑了该州的政治地理特征。这些比较的动机源于一些实例,在这些实例中,MM和PB被用于试图检测某个选区划分计划是否为某党派分配了极端数量的选区。这些实例包括专家证词、面向公众的应用程序、专家向重新划分选区委员会提出的建议以及公共政策提案。为实现这一目标,我们对MM和PB进行了理论和实证分析。在理论分析中,我们考虑了得票率-席位率对(V, S),使得可以构造出得票率为V且席位率为S的选举数据,且每个选区的投票率相等。我们计算了MM和PB在该构造选举数据上可达到的取值范围。在此过程中,我们找到了使MM = 0的(V,S)对的取值范围,并发现PB对应的范围是相同的(V,S)对集合。我们展示了当允许每个选区的投票率变化时,允许MM = 0(以及PB = 0)的此类(V,S)对集合会如何变化。通过观察该理论分析的结果,我们可以证明这些度量所取的值不一定在赢得极端数量选区的计划中达到更极端的值。我们还分析了具体的选举实例,展示了这些度量如何返回不直观的结果。随后我们进行了实证研究,表明在18张不同的美国地图上,这些度量可能无法检测出极端的席位结果。

英文摘要:

We consider two symmetry metrics commonly used to analyze partisan gerrymandering: the Mean-Median Difference (MM) and Partisan Bias (PB). Our main results compare, for combinations of seats and votes achievable in districted elections, the number of districts won by each party to the extent of potential deviation from the ideal metric values, taking into account the political geography of the state. These comparisons are motivated by examples where the MM and PB have been used in efforts to detect when a districting plan awards extreme number of districts won by some party. These examples include expert testimony, public-facing apps, recommendations by experts to redistricting commissions, and public policy proposals. To achieve this goal we perform both theoretical and empirical analyses of the MM and PB. In our theoretical analysis, we consider vote-share, seat-share pairs (V, S) for which one can construct election data having vote share V and seat share S, and turnout is equal in each district. We calculate the range of values that MM and PB can achieve on that constructed election data. In the process, we find the range of (V,S) pairs that achieve MM = 0, and see that the corresponding range for PB is the same set of (V,S) pairs. We show how the set of such (V,S) pairs allowing for MM = 0 (and PB = 0) changes when turnout in each district is allowed to vary. By observing the results of this theoretical analysis, we can show that the values taken on by these metrics do not necessarily attain more extreme values in plans with more extreme numbers of districts won. We also analyze specific example elections, showing how these metrics can return unintuitive results. We follow this with an empirical study, where we show that on 18 different U.S. maps these metrics can fail to detect extreme seats outcomes.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑