生成式AI投票:公平的集体选择对LLM偏见和不一致具有韧性
Generative AI voting: fair collective choice is resilient to LLM biases and inconsistencies
AI总结:
生成式AI投票通过比例选票聚合方法实现公平决策,缓解低参与度和选民疲劳问题。
摘要:
近期生成式人工智能(AI)和大语言模型(LLM)的突破为AI个人助手克服人类认知带宽限制提供了新的能力,能够提供决策支持甚至在大规模上直接代表弃权的人类选民。然而,这种代表的质量以及将集体决策委托给LLM时所显现的潜在偏见是一个紧迫且及时的挑战。通过严格模拟超过50,000个LLM投票身份在363个现实世界投票选举中的行为,我们解构了AI生成的选择如何与人类选择不同以及这如何影响集体决策结果。复杂的偏好选票格式与更简单的多数制选举相比显示出显著的不一致,后者则表现出更高的一致性。引人注目的是,比例选票聚合方法如等份额证明是一种双赢:对人类来说更公平的投票结果,以及对可能弃权的选民更公平的AI代表。这种新的基本关系对于在选民参与率低、选民疲劳的场景中构建民主韧性至关重要:弃权选民通过AI代表得以缓解,这些代表能够恢复代表性和公平的投票结果。这些跨学科见解为政策制定者和公民提供了决策支持,以开发防范在民主创新中使用AI风险的保障措施和政策。
英文摘要:
Recent breakthroughs in generative artificial intelligence (AI) and large language models (LLMs) unravel new capabilities for AI personal assistants to overcome cognitive bandwidth limitations of humans, providing decision support or even direct representation of abstained human voters at large scale. However, the quality of this representation and what underlying biases manifest when delegating collective decision making to LLMs is an alarming and timely challenge to tackle. By rigorously emulating more than >50K LLM voting personas in 363 real-world voting elections, we disentangle how AI-generated choices differ from human choices and how this affects collective decision outcomes. Complex preferential ballot formats show significant inconsistencies compared to simpler majoritarian elections, which demonstrate higher consistency. Strikingly, proportional ballot aggregation methods such as equal shares prove to be a win-win: fairer voting outcomes for humans and fairer AI representation, especially for voters likely to abstain. This novel underlying relationship proves paramount for building democratic resilience in scenarios of low voters turnout by voter fatigue: abstained voters are mitigated via AI representatives that recover representative and fair voting outcomes. These interdisciplinary insights provide decision support to policymakers and citizens for developing safeguards and policies for risks of using AI in democratic innovations.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。