arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2406.03393econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

民主中的审查制度

Censorship in Democracy

Marcel Caesmann, Janis Goldzycher, Matteo Grigoletto, Lorenz Gschwent

AI总结:

本文采用双重差分策略分析欧盟对俄罗斯媒体的禁令,发现禁令短期内降低了用户的亲俄倾向,但两周内即恢复,且其他宣传者加强活动抵消了禁令效果。

摘要:

专制政权宣传、虚假信息和偏见叙事的传播,尤其是社交媒体上的传播,在许多民主国家日益引发担忧。审查能否成为遏制此类偏见叙事传播的有效工具?本文研究了欧洲联盟在2022年俄罗斯入侵乌克兰后对俄罗斯国家主导新闻机构的禁令。我们采用双重差分策略,分析了来自Twitter/X上133,276名用户的775,616条推文。研究表明,该禁令降低了先前曾直接与被封禁机构互动过的用户的亲俄倾向。这种影响在禁令前倾向水平最高的用户中最为显著。然而,该效应是短暂的,倾向在执行后两周内便恢复至禁前水平。此外,我们发现对于禁令前未直接与这些机构互动过的用户,也存在可察觉但较弱的间接影响。我们提供证据表明,其他宣传提供者可能积极通过加强活动来减轻禁令的影响,从而有效抵消了禁令的持续性和影响范围。

英文摘要:

The spread of propaganda, misinformation, and biased narratives from autocratic regimes, especially on social media, is a growing concern in many democracies. Can censorship be an effective tool to curb the spread of such slanted narratives? In this paper, we study the European Union's ban on Russian state-led news outlets after the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine. We analyze 775,616 tweets from 133,276 users on Twitter/X, employing a difference-in-differences strategy. We show that the ban reduced pro-Russian slant among users who had previously directly interacted with banned outlets. The impact is most pronounced among users with the highest pre-ban slant levels. However, this effect was short-lived, with slant returning to its pre-ban levels within two weeks post-enforcement. Additionally, we find a detectable albeit less pronounced indirect effect on users who had not directly interacted with the outlets before the ban. We provide evidence that other suppliers of propaganda may have actively sought to mitigate the ban's influence by intensifying their activity, effectively counteracting the persistence and reach of the ban.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑