arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2406.02798cs.DLcs.CLcs.CY
收藏

科学中的宣传性语言与创新想法的采纳

Promotional Language and the Adoption of Innovative Ideas in Science

Kellogg School of Management, Northwestern University(西北大学凯洛格管理学院);Northwestern Institute on Complex Systems(西北大学复杂系统研究所);Novo Nordisk Foundation(诺和诺德基金会)

Hao Peng, Huilian Sophie Qiu, Henrik Barslund Fosse, Brian Uzzi

AI总结:

本研究通过分析三家顶尖资助机构的数万份基金申请全文,证实科学宣传性语言与创新想法的获批、创新水平及后续学术影响力正相关,并揭示其通过认知激活传递想法价值的机制。

摘要:

科学领域中创新想法的价值是如何被传播的?本文针对科研基金申请的获批情况开展语义分析,重点关注科学宣传性语言——这类语言在诸多场景中的使用频率持续上升,据称能够传达创新想法的原创性与重要性。为克服既往研究的局限性,我们分析了来自三家顶尖公立及私立资助机构的数万份已资助与未资助基金申请的全文,三家机构分别为美国国立卫生研究院(NIH)、美国国家科学基金会(NSF),以及全球最大的私营科学基金会之一诺和诺德基金会(Novo Nordisk Foundation)。研究发现,宣传性语言与资助方及其他科学家对创新想法的支持和采纳之间存在稳定关联。第一,基金申请中宣传性语言的占比最高可使基金获批概率提升一倍。第二,基金申请中的宣传性语言能够反映其内在的创新水平。第三,宣传性语言的占比可预测受资助基金所支持的出版物的预期引用量与学术产出影响力。最后,一项对我们数据中宣传性语言进行调控的计算机辅助实验,揭示了宣传性语言如何通过认知激活来传递想法的价值。鉴于科学领域中宣传性语言的使用频次急剧上升,且基金在将有前景、有抱负的想法转化为解决方案方面发挥着关键作用,本研究提供的实证证据表明,宣传性语言与有效传播创新科学想法的价值存在关联。

英文摘要:

How are the merits of innovative ideas communicated in science? Here we conduct semantic analyses of grant application success with a focus on scientific promotional language, which has been growing in frequency in many contexts and purportedly may convey an innovative idea's originality and significance. Our analysis attempts to surmount limitations of prior studies by examining the full text of tens of thousands of both funded and unfunded grants from three leading public and private funding agencies: the NIH, the NSF, and the Novo Nordisk Foundation, one of the world's largest private science foundations. We find a robust association between promotional language and the support and adoption of innovative ideas by funders and other scientists. First, the percentage of promotional language in a grant proposal is associated with up to a doubling of the grant's probability of being funded. Second, a grant's promotional language reflects its intrinsic level of innovativeness. Third, the percentage of promotional language predicts the expected citation and productivity impact of publications that are supported by funded grants. Lastly, a computer-assisted experiment that manipulates the promotional language in our data demonstrates how promotional language can communicate the merit of ideas through cognitive activation. With the incidence of promotional language in science steeply rising, and the pivotal role of grants in converting promising and aspirational ideas into solutions, our analysis provides empirical evidence that promotional language is associated with effectively communicating the merits of innovative scientific ideas.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑