arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2406.01323cs.CY
收藏

结构性干预与不平等的动态

Structural Interventions and the Dynamics of Inequality

Aurora Zhang, Annette Hosoi

AI总结:

针对算法公平性技术干预的局限性,本文构建决策模型,以抵押贷款为例展示了结构性不平等如何被看似无偏见的机制延续,并指出技术方案须结合外部情境化干预以推动社会变革。

摘要:

算法公平性文献中最近的讨论对标准公平性概念提出了几点担忧。首先,限制预测算法以满足公平性基准可能导致弱势群体的非最优结果。其次,技术干预本身往往无效,尤其是当脱离对产生社会不平等的结构性过程的理解时。受这两点批评启发,我们构建了一个共同的决策模型,以抵押贷款作为贯穿全文的示例。我们表明,在某些条件下,任何决策阈值的选择都不可避免地会延续金融稳定性方面的现有差异,除非偏离帕累托最优策略。然后,我们建模了三种不同类型干预的效果。我们展示了根据对外部参数实施结构性变革的难度以及政策制定者对公平或效率的偏好,如何推荐不同的干预措施。与直觉相反,我们证明了对效率优于公平的偏好可能导致推荐针对资源不足群体的干预措施。最后,我们在一个结合了HMDA和Fannie Mae贷款数据的数据集上模拟了干预效果。本研究强调了结构性不平等如何被看似无偏见的决策机制所延续,并表明在许多情况下,技术解决方案必须与外部的、具有情境意识的干预相结合以推动社会变革。

英文摘要:

Recent conversations in the algorithmic fairness literature have raised several concerns with standard conceptions of fairness. First, constraining predictive algorithms to satisfy fairness benchmarks may lead to non-optimal outcomes for disadvantaged groups. Second, technical interventions are often ineffective by themselves, especially when divorced from an understanding of structural processes that generate social inequality. Inspired by both these critiques, we construct a common decision-making model, using mortgage loans as a running example. We show that under some conditions, any choice of decision threshold will inevitably perpetuate existing disparities in financial stability unless one deviates from the Pareto optimal policy. Then, we model the effects of three different types of interventions. We show how different interventions are recommended depending upon the difficulty of enacting structural change upon external parameters and depending upon the policymaker's preferences for equity or efficiency. Counterintuitively, we demonstrate that preferences for efficiency over equity may lead to recommendations for interventions that target the under-resourced group. Finally, we simulate the effects of interventions on a dataset that combines HMDA and Fannie Mae loan data. This research highlights the ways that structural inequality can be perpetuated by seemingly unbiased decision mechanisms, and it shows that in many situations, technical solutions must be paired with external, context-aware interventions to enact social change.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑