为何算法仍不公正:算法活动背后的权力结构
Why Algorithms Remain Unjust: Power Structures Surrounding Algorithmic Activity
AI总结:
该研究指出算法改良主义因忽视权力结构无法解决算法不公,采用Wright的权力框架分析受经济权力主导的算法活动,提出需赋能终端用户并探讨三类转型路径,构想算法公正需持续评估权力转型。
摘要:
算法在我们的社会生活中无处不在,却往往会延续社会不公。当下流行的解决方式是算法改良主义:微调算法本身,使其更具公平性、可问责性和透明度。然而,改良主义未能遏制算法不公,因为它忽视了算法背后的权力结构。响应批判算法研究的呼吁,我采用Erik Olin Wright提出的框架,研究社会中算法系统(算法活动)周围的权力配置。算法活动之所以不公正,是因为它受经济权力主导。要创造具有社会公正性的算法活动,权力配置必须转而赋能终端用户。我结合公正算法活动的语境,探讨了Wright提出的共生转型、间隙转型和断裂转型。我对算法系统社会公正的构想要求,结合当前结构、社会理论、不断演进的方法论以及个人与权力本身的关系,持续(重新)评估权力如何实现转型。
英文摘要:
Algorithms are unavoidable in our social lives, yet often perpetuate social injustices. The popular means of addressing this is through algorithmic reformism: fine-tuning algorithms themselves to be more fair, accountable, and transparent. However, reformism fails to curtail algorithmic injustice because it ignores the power structure surrounding algorithms. Heeding calls from critical algorithm studies, I employ a framework developed by Erik Olin Wright to examine the configuration of power surrounding algorithmic systems in society (Algorithmic Activity). Algorithmic Activity is unjust because it is dominated by economic power. To create socially just Algorithmic Activity, the power configuration must instead empower end users. I explore Wright's symbiotic, interstitial, and raptural transformations in the context of just Algorithmic Activity. My vision for social justice in algorithmic systems requires a continuous (re)evaluation of how power can be transformed in light of current structure, social theories, evolving methodologies, and one's relationship to power itself.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。