arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2405.11954econ.EMstat.AP
收藏

极短时间内存在不稳定性时的预测能力比较

Comparing predictive ability in presence of instability over a very short time

Fabrizio Iacone, Luca Rossini, Andrea Viselli

AI总结:

针对仅持续极短时间的不稳定性下的预测比较问题,指出全局检验表现不佳,提出采用S检验、MAX过程等非参数方法,经模拟和GDP预测验证后建议评估时排除高局部不稳定短时段。

摘要:

我们研究了不稳定性仅持续较短时段情况下的预测比较问题。研究表明,全局检验在此类场景下表现不佳,因为它们并非为捕捉极短期的不稳定性而设计,且当冲击幅度极大时,其检验功效会完全丧失。随后我们讨论并提出了更适合检测此类情况的方法,例如非参数方法(S检验或MAX过程)。我们通过多项蒙特卡洛模拟实验,以及在包含新冠疫情危机引发GDP不稳定性的时段内,将专业预测者调查(SPF)的美国季度名义GDP即时预测与无增长朴素基准进行对比的评估,验证了上述结果。我们建议预测者不应合并样本,而应将高局部不稳定性的短暂时段从评估工作中排除。

英文摘要:

We consider forecast comparison in the presence of instability when this affects only a short period of time. We demonstrate that global tests do not perform well in this case, as they were not designed to capture very short-lived instabilities, and their power vanishes altogether when the magnitude of the shock is very large. We then discuss and propose approaches that are more suitable to detect such situations, such as nonparametric methods (S test or MAX procedure). We illustrate these results in different Monte Carlo exercises and in evaluating the nowcast of the quarterly US nominal GDP from the Survey of Professional Forecasters (SPF) against a naive benchmark of no growth, over the period that includes the GDP instability brought by the Covid-19 crisis. We recommend that the forecaster should not pool the sample, but exclude the short periods of high local instability from the evaluation exercise.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑