销售相关性信息产品
Pricing Expertise with Information Spillovers
AI总结:
本文研究垄断顾问向有私人信息的客户售卖信息产品的定价问题,考虑状态相关性下的客户套利可能,得出不同剩余分配结论,并解释了实践中常见定价结构的最优性条件。
摘要:
顾问如何为专业知识定价?本文研究了向面临不确定性下决策问题的买方(客户)出售信息产品(专业知识)的问题。客户私下了解自己所需的专业知识类型,以及她对额外信息的支付意愿(WTP)。作为垄断卖方的顾问将信息产品设计为Blackwell实验(即布莱克韦尔实验),这些实验针对与每位客户特定所需专业知识相关的基础状态展开。由于不同状态之间存在相关性,当相关性足够高时,具有高支付意愿的客户可能会发现购买针对低类型客户状态的信息是有利可图的。研究发现,只要此类(边际)收益不超过购买成本更低但噪声更大的信息的(边际)成本,顾问就能获取全部(社会有效)剩余。否则,与机制设计中的典型结果不同,研究发现对信息价值较低以及足够高的买方无法获得信息租金,只有“中间”类型的买方能享有正剩余。当状态间的相关性分别足够高或足够低时,实践中常见的定价结构(如固定费率/小时费率或基于价值的收费)可作为最优合约得到。
英文摘要:
Why do experts charge value-based fees for some services and flat fees for others? For example, an analyst charges the same fee for a stock report whether the client invests a thousand dollars or a million, while an investment bank charges a higher fee for a fairness opinion on a large merger than on a small one. We consider the problem of an expert who sells expertise to a client whose private type determines his project and how much he has at stake. Because project states are correlated, cheaper expertise about a related project can substitute for expertise about his own. We develop a Markov model of information spillovers and provide an explicit characterization of the optimal menu. With perfect spillovers, as with a stock report, a common flat fee for full information is optimal. With sufficiently weak spillovers, as with a fairness opinion, each client receives full information at a value-based fee equal to his willingness to pay. Between these extremes, low types can receive distorted expertise at their full willingness to pay, while middle and high types receive full information. Middle types pay a common base fee plus a project-specific fee that rises with what is at stake, and high types pay a value-based fee equal to their willingness to pay. Because higher types lose more by buying expertise about another project, the project-specific fee can rise faster than willingness to pay, so client surplus can peak among middle types and fall to zero at the top.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。