像女人一样战斗:巴西女性法官与家庭暴力
Fight like a Woman: Domestic Violence and Female Judges in Brazil
AI总结:
研究探讨巴西家庭暴力案件中法官性别对判决结果的影响,发现女性法官更可能获得有罪判决,且此差异源于性别视角差异而非严格性差异,还发现女性法官在审理家庭暴力案件时有更多司法文书和听证会。
摘要:
我们研究了法官性别对家庭暴力案件结果的影响。利用巴西圣保罗2011至2019年的数据,发现分配给女性法官的家庭暴力案件比分配给男性法官的案件有28%(9.7个百分点)更高的定罪率。为了证明这种判决差异源于对家庭暴力的不同性别视角而非女性法官在所有判决中更严格,我们比较了类似犯罪类型的性别定罪率差异。我们发现家庭暴力案件的差异比其他身体伤害案件的差异更大(8.5个百分点)。此外,我们发现至少有两个渠道解释了家庭暴力案件的性别定罪率差异:性别差异在证据解读和量刑标准上的差异。我们还发现,女性法官在审理家庭暴力案件时会撰写更长的判决书,安排更多听证会,并撰写更多司法文件。最后,我们发现性别定罪率差异对上诉、判决撤销或再犯概率没有显著影响。
英文摘要:
We investigate whether female judges analyze domestic violence cases differently from their male peers. Using data from São Paulo, Brazil, between 2011 and 2019, we find that a domestic violence case assigned to a female judge is 28% (9.7 p.p.) more likely to result in a conviction than a case assigned to a male judge with similar career characteristics. To show that this decision gap rises due to different gender perspectives about domestic violence and not because female judges are stricter than their male counterparts in all rulings, we compare it against the gender conviction-rate gap in similar types of crime. We find that this gap for domestic violence cases is larger than the same gap for other physical assault cases (8.3 p.p.). Furthermore, we analyze two explanatory channels for this gender conviction-rate gap for domestic violence cases: gender-based differences in evidence interpretation and gender-based sentencing criteria. We also find that female judges write longer sentences, schedule more hearings, and write more judicial documents than their male peers when analyzing domestic violence cases. Lastly, we find that the gender conviction-rate gap has no significant impact on the probability of appeals, ruling reversals, or recidivism.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。