arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2405.00995cs.CY
收藏

并非瑞士军刀:学术界对生成式人工智能使用中权衡的认知

Not a Swiss Army Knife: Academics' Perceptions of Trade-Offs Around Generative Artificial Intelligence Use

Afsaneh Razi, Layla Bouzoubaa, Aria Pessianzadeh, John S. Seberger, Rezvaneh Rezapour

AI总结:

本文通过访谈17位高校师生,揭示学术界对生成式AI在透明度、师生信任、知识民主化及权力失衡等方面的权衡认知,为教育场景中的伦理使用提供见解。

摘要:

在计算学科快速演变的格局中,大量努力正致力于揭示生成式人工智能(Gen AI)的社会技术影响。尽管现有研究已以多种形式呈现,但在学术界知识工作者直接参与Gen AI方面仍存在显著空白。我们访谈了17位知识工作者,包括教师和学生,以从他们的视角考察Gen AI的社会与技术维度。参与者对用于训练Gen AI的数据不透明性提出了担忧。这种透明度的缺乏使得识别和处理这些模型所生成的不准确、有偏见且可能有害的信息变得困难。知识工作者还表达了对Gen AI削弱师生关系中信任的担忧,并讨论了诸如教学法准备等潜在解决方案以缓解这些问题。此外,参与者认识到Gen AI有潜力通过加速学习过程使知识民主化,并充当可及的研究助手。然而,也有人担心因获取此类技术的机会不均而可能产生的社会与权力失衡。我们的研究提供了关于知识工作者对Gen AI在教育环境及其他场景中伦理使用的担忧与期望的见解,并对如何驾驭这一新格局具有启示意义。

英文摘要:

In the rapidly evolving landscape of computing disciplines, substantial efforts are being dedicated to unraveling the sociotechnical implications of generative AI (Gen AI). While existing research has manifested in various forms, there remains a notable gap concerning the direct engagement of knowledge workers in academia with Gen AI. We interviewed 17 knowledge workers, including faculty and students, to investigate the social and technical dimensions of Gen AI from their perspective. Our participants raised concerns about the opacity of the data used to train Gen AI. This lack of transparency makes it difficult to identify and address inaccurate, biased, and potentially harmful, information generated by these models. Knowledge workers also expressed worries about Gen AI undermining trust in the relationship between instructor and student and discussed potential solutions, such as pedagogy readiness, to mitigate them. Additionally, participants recognized Gen AI's potential to democratize knowledge by accelerating the learning process and act as an accessible research assistant. However, there were also concerns about potential social and power imbalances stemming from unequal access to such technologies. Our study offers insights into the concerns and hopes of knowledge workers about the ethical use of Gen AI in educational settings and beyond, with implications for navigating this new landscape.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑