抵押贷款中的种族与族裔差异:来自扩展版 HMDA 数据的新证据
Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Mortgage Lending: New Evidence from Expanded HMDA Data
AI总结:
本文基于扩展版HMDA数据研究美国抵押贷款中的种族与族裔差异,发现信用评分、收入和首付要求显著造成信贷获取与定价差距,但批准差异无法仅由可观测信用因素解释,表明存在其他系统性障碍。
摘要:
本文利用近乎全量的美国抵押贷款申请数据,考察了不同种族和族裔在住房信贷获取与成本方面的差距。我们的数据包含借款人信用状况变量,这些变量在历史上一直缺失于全行业申请数据中,并且很可能影响贷款申请的批准和贷款定价。我们发现,不同种族和族裔群体之间在贷款批准和定价方面存在巨大的无条件差异。在对可观测的借款人信用状况关键要素进行条件控制后,这些差异有所缩小,但在经济上仍然显著。敏感性分析表明,即使存在与信用评分对批准/定价和种族/族裔具有同等预测能力的遗漏因素,也只能解释部分定价差异,而无法解释批准差异。综合来看,我们的结果表明,信用评分、收入和首付要求显著导致了抵押贷款获取和可负担性方面的差异,但其他系统性障碍也对抵押贷款市场中大部分差异性结果负有责任。
英文摘要:
This paper investigates gaps in access to and the cost of housing credit by race and ethnicity using the near universe of U.S. mortgage applications. Our data contain borrower creditworthiness variables that have historically been absent from industry-wide application data and that are likely to affect application approval and loan pricing. We find large unconditional disparities in approval and pricing between racial and ethnic groups. After conditioning on key elements of observable borrower creditworthiness, these disparities are smaller but remain economically meaningful. Sensitivity analysis indicates that omitted factors as predictive of approval/pricing and race/ethnicity as credit score can explain some of the pricing disparities but cannot explain the approval disparities. Taken together, our results suggest that credit score, income, and down payment requirements significantly contribute to disparities in mortgage access and affordability but that other systemic barriers are also responsible for a large share of disparate outcomes in the mortgage market.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。