应用研究人员如何使用 Causal Forest?一种方法的方法论回顾
How do applied researchers use the Causal Forest? A methodological review of a method
AI总结:
本文回顾了133篇论文中对causal forest方法的应用,发现新兴最佳实践高度依赖原作者的grf包等工具,常用于低维数据集并通过多种图表展示处理效应分布,同时指出了部分偏离常规做法的利弊及未来研究方向。
摘要:
本方法论回顾考察了应用研究人员在133篇同行评审论文中对causal forest方法的使用情况。结果表明,新兴的最佳实践严重依赖于causal forest原作者创建的方法和工具,例如他们的grf包以及他们在示例中给出的方法。通常,研究人员在相对低维的数据集上使用causal forest,依靠观测控制变量,或在某些情况下依靠实验来识别效应。随后,有几种常见的方式来交流结果——通过描绘个体层面处理效应估计的单变量分布,展示森林的变量重要性结果,并绘制处理效应在协变量上的分布图,这些协变量之所以重要,要么是出于理论原因,要么是因为它们具有很高的变量重要性。一些偏离这种常见做法的偏差很有趣,值得进一步发展和使用。其他一些偏差则是不必要的,甚至是有害的。本文最后反思了causal forest使用的新兴最佳实践以及未来研究的路径。
英文摘要:
This methodological review examines the use of the causal forest method by applied researchers across 133 peer-reviewed papers. It shows that the emerging best practice relies heavily on the approach and tools created by the original authors of the causal forest such as their grf package and the approaches given by them in examples. Generally researchers use the causal forest on a relatively low-dimensional dataset relying on observed controls or in some cases experiments to identify effects. There are several common ways to then communicate results -- by mapping out the univariate distribution of individual-level treatment effect estimates, displaying variable importance results for the forest and graphing the distribution of treatment effects across covariates that are important either for theoretical reasons or because they have high variable importance. Some deviations from this common practice are interesting and deserve further development and use. Others are unnecessary or even harmful. The paper concludes by reflecting on the emerging best practice for causal forest use and paths for future research.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。