arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2404.05429cs.HC
收藏

通过建设性与好奇心对新闻评论重新排序可显著提升感知尊重度、可信度与兴趣度

Re-Ranking News Comments by Constructiveness and Curiosity Significantly Increases Perceived Respect, Trustworthiness, and Interest

Emily Saltz, Zaria Jalan, Tin Acosta

AI总结:

本研究通过对460名美国新闻读者的富媒体实验,发现按建设性、好奇心等亲社会特质对新闻评论重新排序,可依文章类型不同提升评论区的尊重度、可信度等,为促进健康网络对话提供了新方向。

摘要:

在线评论平台通常开发了通过移除和降低内容排序来应对网络危害的系统。另一种尚未得到充分探索的替代方法是聚焦于提升内容排序,主动优先展示亲社会评论并树立更好的对话规范。我们开展了一项有460名说英语的美国新闻读者参与的研究,旨在了解按建设性、好奇心和个人故事对评论重新排序,对参与意愿、互动意愿,以及评论区感知可信度和极化程度等各类结果的影响。在我们的富媒体调查实验中,处于四种排序条件和一个对照组的参与者,查看了一篇政治专栏文章和一篇美食文章的评论区原型。我们发现,结果因文章类型存在显著差异。提升好奇心和建设性内容的排序改善了政治文章的多项衡量指标,包括评论区的感知尊重度、可信度和趣味性。建设性排序还提升了人们认为评论对共和党人持支持态度的感知,且没有任何一种排序条件会恶化对党派人士的看法。此外,在美食文章中,个人故事和建设性排序显著提升了评论的感知信息量。总体而言,这些发现表明,将言语的亲社会特质纳入排序机制,可能是促进在线评论区更健康、更少极化对话的一种有前景的方法。

英文摘要:

Online commenting platforms have commonly developed systems to address online harms by removing and down-ranking content. An alternative, under-explored approach is to focus on up-ranking content to proactively prioritize prosocial commentary and set better conversational norms. We present a study with 460 English-speaking US-based news readers to understand the effects of re-ranking comments by constructiveness, curiosity, and personal stories on a variety of outcomes related to willingness to participate and engage, as well as perceived credibility and polarization in a comment section. In our rich-media survey experiment, participants across these four ranking conditions and a control group reviewed prototypes of comment sections of a Politics op-ed and Dining article. We found that outcomes varied significantly by article type. Up-ranking curiosity and constructiveness improved a number of measures for the Politics article, including perceived Respect, Trustworthiness, and Interestingness of the comment section. Constructiveness also increased perceptions that the comments were favorable to Republicans, with no condition worsening perceptions of partisans. Additionally, in the Dining article, personal stories and constructiveness rankings significantly improved the perceived informativeness of the comments. Overall, these findings indicate that incorporating prosocial qualities of speech into ranking could be a promising approach to promote healthier, less polarized dialogue in online comment sections.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑